Big Media Eagerly Leaps at Bogus Story About Chlamydia Outbreak at Texas Abstinence-Only School
The story swept Big Media this past week — and how could it not? The stupidity of those absurd West Texans, and the predictable and ironically horrific results . . . well, it was a story tailor-made for our betters in Big Media, and they lapped it up:
The Washington Post: Texas high school with chlamydia outbreak has abstinence-only sex ed
ABCNews: Chlamydia Outbreak Hits Texas High School With No Sex Ed
TIME: Chlamydia Outbreak Hits Texas High School With Abstinence-Only Sex-Ed Program
Amanda Marcotte at Slate: One in 15 Students at a West Texas High School Has Chlamydia
People Magazine: Chlamydia Outbreak at Texas High School with Abstinence-Only Sex-Ed Program
N.Y. Daily News: Chlamydia outbreak hits abstinence-only Texas high school, making officials rethink sex ed
AOL.com: An ‘abstinence-only’ Texas high school has chlamydia outbreak
Only one major blogger seemed to express skepticism: Instapundit. But aside from him, even “conservative” sites were not immune:
The Daily Caller: This Texas High School Is CRAWLING WITH VENEREAL DISEASE
There’s just one problem: the story was bogus.
A previously reported group of chlamydia cases at a West Texas high school is much smaller than initially thought, according to the state health department.
Reports of 20 confirmed cases among the 300 or so students at Crane High School drew national headlines this week and were largely based on comments and a letter sent by the small school district’s superintendent. On Thursday, a spokeswoman with the Texas Department of State Health Services said there have only been three confirmed cases in the county and those were not necessarily students.
What’s more, the news of only three confirmed cases in the county was known to local media on May 6. Yet several of the pieces above — such as the ones in the Washington Post and TIME — were published later, on May 7.
They should have known better — and if the story contradicted their innate prejudices, they would have checked.
Instead, they published crap, with a side helping of snark.
Christian publications are publishing the corrected story, but that’s about it. I don’t see a single correction appended to any of the stories linked above.
They had their agenda, and they weren’t going to let facts get in the way.
UPDATE: The Washington Post has now “clarified” the story since the publication of my post last night:
Clarification: The original version of this story quoting Texas media said 20 cases had been reported in the school, and did not reflect the superintendent’s latest comments saying there were eight this year in the county as a whole, not necessarily all in the school.
That’s all year. There are three or possibly four confirmed cases in the county right now. That’s out of a county of about 5000 people.