President Biden Cautions Prime Minister Netanyahu
[guest post by Dana]
President Biden had a strained conversation with Prime Minister Netanyahu on the heels of seven World Central Kitchen aid workers killed by Israeli military forces. (WCK head José Andres said that “he believed the seven aid workers killed by the strike in Gaza were targeted “systematically, car by car.” An investigation is underway.)
“President Biden emphasized that the strikes on humanitarian workers and the overall humanitarian situation are unacceptable,” the White House said in a statement. “He made clear the need for Israel to announce and implement a series of specific, concrete, and measurable steps to address civilian harm, humanitarian suffering, and the safety of aid workers. He made clear that U.S. policy with respect to Gaza will be determined by our assessment of Israel’s immediate action on these steps.”
Additionally:
John F. Kirby, a White House spokesman, said the president wants to see “concrete tangible steps” to reduce the violence against civilians and increase access for humanitarian aid to Gaza. He said the White House expects Israel to make announcements of specific changes within hours or days.
But Mr. Kirby would not outline specific metrics for judging Israel’s response or what Mr. Biden would do if not satisfied. “What we want to see are some real changes on the Israeli side and, you know, if we don’t see changes from their side there will have to be changes from our side,” he said.
BREAKING: Biden told Netanyahu an immediate ceasefire is essential to stabilize & improve the humanitarian situation & protect innocent civilians & he urged Netanyahu to empower his negotiators to conclude a deal without delay to bring the hostages home, the White House says
— Barak Ravid (@BarakRavid) April 4, 2024
Hamas should be feeling pretty encourage right about now.
—Dana
Hello.
Dana (8e902f) — 4/4/2024 @ 1:11 pmQuick work, Jill.
BuDuh (4214e4) — 4/4/2024 @ 1:18 pmOne, Biden is a coward, both with Russia and Hamas.
Two, Hamas needs to be destroyed, the sooner the better, so Israel should be reticent to take any act that prolongs their existence, such as a unilateral ceasefire.
Three, there can’t be a true ceasefire unless Hamas also ceases fire, which they won’t.
Four, a ceasefire helps Hamas, on multiple fronts. They’re better able to re-arm, and they’ll be diverting humanitarian aid to their benefit.
Five, Netanyahu may be the wrong leader for his war, but he needs to ignore Biden’s dithering and finish the job. On to Rafah.
Paul Montagu (d4d407) — 4/4/2024 @ 1:26 pmIsrael should leave no stone unturned in Rafah. Raze it.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 4/4/2024 @ 1:48 pmKirby with the quote of the day, after questioning from Peter Doocy…
Might want to circle back on that one, Admiral…
https://twitter.com/CurtisHouck/status/1775966831762637202
SaveFarris (79ab12) — 4/4/2024 @ 2:00 pmI will add a couple of comments as well:
1. I left this one on a similar post over at NRO: At a bare minimum, the White House should be demanding that Hamas unconditionally return all of its hostages as a mandatory step that must be completed before any ceasefire negotiations can begin. But the Biden Administration is far too stupid and weak to stand behind that.
2. Another NRO piece quotes a Senator Peter Welch of Vermont (I didn’t recall ever hearing of him before, but I guess he’s the clown who replaced Patrick Leahy) opining that this FUBAR situation is “more tragic evidence that the way the Netanyahu government is conducting this war is terribly wrong.” I went to read Sen. Welch’s online biography to determine where his military expertise in the Middle East comes from, but apparently he’s spent his whole life as a left-wing activist, an ambulance chasing lawyer, and for 30 out of the last 40 years an elected official at some level of government. Then it dawned upon me: Sen. Welch isn’t looking at the IDF’s campaign in Gaza through a military lens, he’s looking at it entirely through a political lens. And I guess that’s why our nation no longer has too many leaders who can steer us through tense military engagements.
JVW (b02843) — 4/4/2024 @ 2:04 pmI am concerned that the hostages being freed is not a priority, or worse, somewhat forgotten. Conveniently so. That is obviously the priority of Israel, but only Israel, and that is obviously going to prevent anything like a ceasefire from happening. It’s disappointing that the administration has followed the lead of pro-Palestinians.
Dana (8e902f) — 4/4/2024 @ 3:47 pmThere were multiple strikes by drone. This was confirmed by a Gazan group, who, this time, had their safe conduct honored, as it usually is.
Paul Montagu (d4d407) — 4/4/2024 @ 1:26 pm
They won’t even agree to one,exceot under unacceptable terms – unacceptable even according to Biden because Biden says that those responsible for October 7 must be turned out to Israel, and the hostages also, without conditions.
It’s not Netanyahu, except that he is leaving too much of the war to the generals – the same people who let October 7 happen. They’ve got a reputation for knowing what to do to uphold and they’ve got blame to deflect.
Biden needs to stop being influenced by Hamas propaganda, which is corrupting people’s judgement. At the same time, he needs to get Israel to properly diagnose the problem, and offer to send people over (hopefully the right ones) and see what’s going on.
It may be targeting that is essentially being done by AI.
That wouldn’t have happened at the hospital. No civilians or patients were killed in the second attack on al-Shifa hospital. Interestingly, it was reported that in the hospital itself they got more surrenders and less fighting to the bitter end than in the buildings on the periphery. Maybe they went slower and gave them more time in the important parts of the hospital grounds. Partly because they really, really didn’t want to destroy more important infrastructure (the maternity ward and emergency room wasn’t actually in use any more but occupied by Hamas.)
especially at night, or when the battlefield gets complicated and humans are overwhelmed, AI probably gets used more, or used with less supervision and deliberation.
The upper echelons of the military, which is anti-Netanyahu. and its allies in politics, wants to get the blame placed on Netanyahu, rather than the professionals, for October 7 and for anything else. It could be so bad that some people in the Israeli military might deliberately not be correcting bad systems – all to get rid of Netanyahu. But this must be found out.
Benny Gantz the other day called for elections by September. There’s a lot of maneuvering going on. There are stupid demonstrations going on in Israel. Plus creating a government crisis about the drafting of yeshiva students.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 4/4/2024 @ 4:03 pmDana (8e902f) — 4/4/2024 @ 3:47 pm
There were those in the IDF, particularly in the early days, who wanted to write off the hostages. They wanted full speed ahead.
It’s somewhat typical of both the Obama and the Biden Administrations in foreign policy, particularly with regard to Iran, to want to make compromises with reality.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 4/4/2024 @ 4:07 pm6. JVW (b02843) — 4/4/2024 @ 2:04 pm
Again, it’s Netanyahu, Netanyahu, Netanyahu. It’s not Netanyahu.
It’s the career professionals.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 4/4/2024 @ 4:11 pmThe pro-Palestinian propaganda which is influencing me is from the New York Times and it’s pictures of women and children surrounded by rubble. I don’t like to see that, and six months is too long for me to hold a mad and disregard that these are people.
I have no solution. But with every day that goes by I am less and less comfortable with my country taking part in that cruelty.
nk (bb1548) — 4/4/2024 @ 4:26 pmThere is nothing quite like Americans trying to micromanage another country’s war from halfway around the world during an election year.
norcal (73161b) — 4/4/2024 @ 4:30 pmNext up: Trump will come out and say how he can end this war in 24 hours*.
*Of course, he won’t provide any details as to how he will accomplish this, just as he never provides details for his outlandish claims, whether it’s the Ukraine conflict, eliminating the national debt, or replacing Obamacare.
norcal (73161b) — 4/4/2024 @ 4:51 pmI hate it when Trump appropriates my policies:
nk (bb1548) — 4/4/2024 @ 5:02 pmF’n DrUMph!!!!
norcal!! Thank you so much for bringing him up on this thread!! Yeah!! Hell YEAH!
(My dad used to tell this joke about why he disliked atheists… all they wanted to do was talk about God.)
BuDuh (2165ed) — 4/4/2024 @ 5:03 pmTrump gets it, and if he does not his advisors do. Americans, and I’m proud to count myself among them, do not like to see people getting kicked around for very long.
nk (bb1548) — 4/4/2024 @ 5:07 pmFrom the link within norcal’s StUPid DrUMpH link:
What an idiot!!! We need Biden!!!
BuDuh (2165ed) — 4/4/2024 @ 5:09 pmOops!!
My apologies nk. I was too quick on the draw.
Full retraction.
We have been doing very well here and I hate to muck it up by this unforced error.
BuDuh (2165ed) — 4/4/2024 @ 5:11 pmFrom the link within norcal’s StUPid DrUMpH link:
BuDuh (2165ed) — 4/4/2024 @ 5:09 pm
What link? And who is being stupid?
norcal (73161b) — 4/4/2024 @ 5:14 pmI think Israel’s strategy in releasing so much video of their campaign in Gaza is to preempt what would otherwise be ridiculous claims by Hamas and their media allies that bombs are falling directly on women and children. In a lot of ways, Israel is in a no-win mess: if they keep quiet then the worst sort of blood libels are bound to spread, but when they release actual footage then it gets misrepresented by their antagonists.
Noah Rothman makes a good case for how general ignorance of artillery and modern weapons-guidance makes Israel’s assault on Gaza sound much worse than it really is:
No surprise there: ignorant journalists serve the interests of nasty despots in order to strike a blow against a conservative government that they find distasteful.
JVW (b02843) — 4/4/2024 @ 5:32 pmPerfectly understandable, BuDuh.
nk (bb1548) — 4/4/2024 @ 5:44 pmI was with my family over Easter. My dad is retired military and one of the things he did was, um, targeting related. He took one look at the exploded aid workers car video and said that it was unmistakeably purposeful. That there was no way anyone guiding that strike could’ve hit them by mistake. Make of that what you will.
My concern about the whole conflict is that the main chess pieces are mostly in other countries and all Israel is doing at this point (probably already having removed most of the incountry Hamas infrastructure) is killing pawns and angering the international community.
Nic (896fdf) — 4/4/2024 @ 5:47 pmDespite the Biden Administration’s handwringing over Gaza, there is no evidence that the administration has cut off military aid to Israel; in fact quite the opposite.
And it has continued:
Even if some of the actual transfers won’t occur for years (such as the F-35 fighters), the fact that the Biden Administration hasn’t cancelled the transactions speaks to fact the Biden Administration has refused to kowtow to its left wing.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 4/4/2024 @ 5:56 pmHe took one look at the exploded aid workers car video and said that it was unmistakeably purposeful. That there was no way anyone guiding that strike could’ve hit them by mistake. Make of that what you will.
I don’t think anyone doubts that the IDF targeted those WCK trucks. The question is whether they knew what they were targeting. The IDF had been in contact with WCK and knew when and where the trucks were making the rounds, but the delivery that they attacked was done in the darkness of night and it might have been hard to see the WCK logos. Still, we will likely find out that the IDF should have known about this convoy, though it isn’t out of the question that WCK failed to communicate it in advance. But if I had to wager, I would guess this is just incredibly regrettable human error rather than actual malice.
JVW (b02843) — 4/4/2024 @ 6:05 pmMy concern about the whole conflict is that the main chess pieces are mostly in other countries and all Israel is doing at this point (probably already having removed most of the incountry Hamas infrastructure) is killing pawns and angering the international community.
That is of course a legitimate issue, but Israel has had some success in killing the masterminds of the attacks as well as some nasty high-ranking Hamas operatives in nations like Syria and Lebanon.
JVW (b02843) — 4/4/2024 @ 6:10 pmAdded to post: Hamas should be feeling pretty encourage right about now.
Israel is not helping itself by killing the seven aid workers. I read that there is an increasing concern about young IDF troops. They are hung-ho and operating with little discipline. Officers are unsure of how prevalent this is, but judging from the awful videos they’ve posted, it’s happening enough that disciplinary action needs to start ramping up.
Dana (8e902f) — 4/4/2024 @ 6:13 pmJVW @ 25,
While you’re correct, I guess I want to know how and by whom the subsequent vacuum of power will be filled?
Dana (8e902f) — 4/4/2024 @ 6:14 pmIsrael needs to go full war and end Hamas, permanently.
How many drove strikes did Obama, Bush kill innocents with?
That’s war.
NJRob (23cd49) — 4/4/2024 @ 7:10 pmNJRob: don’t get me wrong, I agree with most of your positions here, and I’m sure you’re a really likeable guy in person.
But sometimes, like your comment at #28 above, you sound a bit like a real-life version of Larry Linville’s Frank Burns. 🙂
(Gen-Xers like me and older here will know what/who I’m talking about.)
Still waiting for you to say to Rip, “nertz to you!!” 😉
qdpsteve again (7e84f9) — 4/4/2024 @ 7:24 pmBut if I had to wager, I would guess this is just incredibly regrettable human error rather than actual malice.
Neither Israel nor the IDF is a monolith and there is a minority of those in power in Israel who would like nothing better than to drive the Palestinians into the sea (just as that is Hamas’ goal for Israel).
I see it as likely that someone arranged for this mistake to happen, to send a message to those bringing aid into Gaza. The politics here are complex.
Kevin M (a9545f) — 4/4/2024 @ 7:37 pmWhat I wonder is how Netanyahu’s troubles might be prolonging this war.
It seems likely that there will be elections shortly after the war, and that the ruling coalition will have to answer for their failures. I doubt that Netanyahu has another recovery left in him. Is he going to widen the war to stay in power?
One can support Israel while also thinking that Benjamin Netanyahu is a long-term disaster.
Kevin M (a9545f) — 4/4/2024 @ 7:43 pmKevin M, I’m not sure who’s had more comebacks: Netanyahu or Cher.
qdpsteve again (7e84f9) — 4/4/2024 @ 7:55 pm😉
Clarification:
My comment at 12 was not directed at any commenters here, but rather the people being quoted in Dana’s main piece.
norcal (8124b5) — 4/4/2024 @ 7:59 pmSteve,
I am blunter on here to try and wake people up a bit. Hamas would murder every Israeli if they could. They don’t care. Biden only cares about votes, not doing what is right or necessary.
NJRob (eb56c3) — 4/4/2024 @ 8:34 pmNJRob, fair enough.
qdpsteve again (7e84f9) — 4/4/2024 @ 8:39 pmAlso let’s be honest: most of Biden’s “staffers” (i.e. hardcore SJWs) masturbate themselves to sleep at night, dreaming of Israel’s destruction.
Update:
Dana (8e902f) — 4/4/2024 @ 8:47 pm@36 Has netanyahu been fired yet? From the beginning I have posted that Israel has limited time to destroy hamas. The bottle deposit crook has delayed destroying hamas to stay in power as long as possible. He cares about being voted out of office with the rest of the likud gang and into a jail cell. The hostages are an inconvenience for him.
asset (0c0305) — 4/4/2024 @ 9:10 pmIt’s also concerning that the 1,300 killed by Hamas on Oct. 7 don’t even factor in to the current calculations by President Biden.
Dana (8e902f) — 4/4/2024 @ 9:59 pm@38 How do you factor it in? 30,000 palestinians civilians mostly women and children have been killed who had nothing to do with the murder of 1.300 Israeli. Most americans say kill hamas fighters not women and children ;but the numbers dwindle as the number of children killed keeps increasing. I factored it in by advocating wiping out hamas not women children. I said do it as fast as possible and this why. As a lefty I saw this coming and kept saying hurry.
asset (0c0305) — 4/4/2024 @ 10:20 pmHe also fires Nachal Bde chief of staff, and brigade fire support officer
This seems a bit much for a mistake. I think he found out it was more than that.
Kevin M (a9545f) — 4/4/2024 @ 10:21 pmBiden has backed Israel to the hilt where it counts. He may complain about Israeli strategy, but he hasn’t done anything about it. There is no evidence that the Administration has restricted delivery of weapons to Israel, no matter what Israel has done. Without our weapon deliveries, Israel couldn’t carry on the war as it has.
And he has paid a political price for that support. If Biden was concerned about what Democrats thought about his support of Israel, he would have cutoff Israel a long time ago.
Rip Murdock (3d201b) — 4/4/2024 @ 10:52 pmProbably because he agrees with what Israel should do in Rafah.
Rip Murdock (3d201b) — 4/4/2024 @ 10:56 pm@41 Michigan, minnesota and wisconsin are clawing at biden’s campaign and it getting worse not better. Look at bien’s primary results and these are democrat voters.
asset (0c0305) — 4/4/2024 @ 10:57 pmMy point exactly-Biden being on the right side of history costs him votes.
Rip Murdock (3d201b) — 4/4/2024 @ 11:36 pm@44 Biden is on the wrong side of democratic party history. The left now has allies in democrat muslims and black men are splitting from trump populism all the way to hard militant left. Like atlanta where armed black miltants and antifa were ready to confront the klan which ran away. Biden still has minority and older white pro-choice women. Younger democrats think biden is senile and like in 2016 vote green party or RFK jr. My support of Israel is not being shared by young democrats thanks to netanyahu antics.
asset (0c0305) — 4/5/2024 @ 3:24 amThe difference between the two parties:
The Republicans want to go back to the 1950s.
The Democrats want to go back to the 1970s.
The voters dislike both ideas, but those are their choices.
Kevin M (a9545f) — 4/5/2024 @ 6:18 amYou can sell them the bombs. Or Russia can sell them the bombs. Or they can blow their trumpets and break their pots. As long as America does not give them the bombs. Or trumpets and pots.
nk (bb1548) — 4/5/2024 @ 6:41 amNeither Israel nor the IDF is a monolith and there is a minority of those in power in Israel who would like nothing better than to drive the Palestinians into the sea (just as that is Hamas’ goal for Israel).
It is the inevitable consummation, whether devoutly wished or not, of Israel’s Basic Law (that Israel is a Jewish Nation State) and the 1950 Law of Return (that every Jew has a right to emigrate to Israel) in that handkerchief-sized piece of land less than one-fifth the size of Arizona.
No San Carlos big enough for the Palestinians and no Tom Jeffords either.
nk (bb1548) — 4/5/2024 @ 7:00 amWrong, The peace treaty with Jordan came in between.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel%E2%80%93Jordan_peace_treaty
Sammy Finkelman (c2c77e) — 4/5/2024 @ 3:27 pmThe co-ordination plan was not passed down through all he units if the Israeli army, This was also not the first time that aid came under attack or nearly so, They also once killed two telephone repair workers – and Israel wants the phone lines repaired (to eavesdrop presumably) And came close to killing telephone workers before,
The trucks were attacked at 11:09, 11:11 and 11:13, One person carrying abag was identified as a Hamas fighter carrying a gun
Sammy Finkelman (c2c77e) — 4/5/2024 @ 3:44 pmPro-Israel outnumbers anti-Israel (or more inclined to support a politician who is) by almost two to one,But Biden wants to please everyone,
Sammy Finkelman (c2c77e) — 4/5/2024 @ 3:47 pmAmong all voters.
Sammy Finkelman (c2c77e) — 4/5/2024 @ 3:59 pmBiden and his State Dept are right to urge Israel to do better, but the Bidenistas are behaving as if the USA and the Biden Administration is above all of that when the truth is we’ve had our own dozens of errant strikes and brushed them off.
August 29, 2021
NY Times
“No U.S. Troops Will Be Punished for Deadly Kabul Strike, Pentagon Chief Decides
steveg (dd7c66) — 4/5/2024 @ 7:37 pmThe military initially defended the strike, which killed 10 civilians including seven children, but ultimately called it a tragic mistake.”
It’s not your granddaddy’s war.
We’re not talking about footsloggers, themselves an instant’s away from death, crawling in the dust; smelling the blood and hearing the screams of the wounded, their comrades’ and the enemies’.
We’re talking about Game Con nerds in ergonomic chairs playing video games and wishing they had better graphics and a bag of Cheetos to munch on as they guide drones and push buttons to launch Hellfire missiles.
And they give the dweebs medals for it.
nk (bb1548) — 4/6/2024 @ 6:44 amUkraine hitting Russian oil facilities is hitting “civilian targets”. I agree. Some civilians of USA will vote against Biden if gas prices are high.
steveg (478c0d) — 4/11/2024 @ 8:27 amUkraine Foreign Minister at a NATO 75th birtday meeting take a piss on the festivities because his people are dying:
” “I’m sorry to spoil the birthday party, but who can believe that the mightiest military alliance in the world cannot find seven batteries of Patriots to provide them to the only country in the world that is fighting ballistic attacks every day?”
steveg (478c0d) — 4/11/2024 @ 8:30 amRaytheon says it can build one Patriot system a month
steveg (478c0d) — 4/11/2024 @ 8:30 amAnd they give the dweebs medals for it.
But no “V”s
Kevin M (a9545f) — 4/11/2024 @ 8:44 amRaytheon says it can build one Patriot system a month
They could build a lot more if they wanted to.
Kevin M (a9545f) — 4/11/2024 @ 8:47 am