Weekend Open Thread
[guest post by Dana]
[Reminder: Below the Weekend Open Thread, JVW has provided an open thread focused solely on today’s Supreme Court decisions.]
Let’s go!
First news item
When you willfully refuse to provide help to a victim in their fight against a genocidal maniac, you are not being neutral. Try complicit, indifferent, moral cowardice. You choose. And if you babble about how warfare is not part of the Swiss DNA, you will be treated with scorn you richly deserve:
Switzerland has vetoed a plan to export nearly 100 mothballed Leopard battle tanks to Ukraine, citing neutrality laws for a decision made just as Kyiv’s counteroffensive enters a decisive phase.
Bern’s veto is likely to spark anger among Switzerland’s European allies, who for months have been pressing the government to relax its restrictive interpretation of a long-cherished neutrality policy.
The tanks have never been in service in Switzerland, were never intended for use by the Swiss military and are not based in the country. All 96 are stored in Italy, having been acquired in 2016 from the Italian military in a private transaction by the Swiss arms manufacturer Ruag…
The decision deepens the wealthy alpine country’s diplomatic isolation in Europe, as it tries to steer a path that protects one of its most venerated national political principles, while also seeking to maintain economic ties with the west and cast itself as a moral critic of Russian aggression.
Note:
[T]e 96 tanks in question have never even been on Swiss soil, and were acquired from Italy’s military seven years ago as part of a commercial enterprise by Ruag. The company planned to sell them on to third countries anyway, after it had refurbished them.
Related…sort of: Ukrainian soldiers grateful to U.S. for sending Bradley Fighting Vehicles:
As Ukrainian forces continue their counteroffensive against Russia, some soldiers say an American-supplied vehicle is making a key difference in their advances, and more importantly, saving lives…
Two Ukrainian soldiers from the 47th brigade, Serhiy and Andriy, told ABC News that they and their crew wouldn’t be alive today if Bradley didn’t protect them from a battle early on in the counteroffensive where they were struck by mines, high caliber guns and attack drones.
“We were hit multiple times,” Andriy, who drove one Bradley, said. “Thanks to it, I am standing here now. If we were using some Soviet armored personnel carrier we would all probably be dead after the first hit. It’s a perfect vehicle.”
Second news item
As the war intensifies, U.S. considers sending cluster munitions to Ukraine:
The Biden administration is actively considering sending cluster munitions to Ukraine to help Kyiv’s counteroffensive punch through Russia’s defenses, two U.S. officials and a person familiar with the debate said.
The discussion to send dual-purpose improved conventional munitions has intensified in recent days as Ukraine’s effort to break through Russia’s frontline has stalled. The belief among some senior U.S. officials is that the munitions could be one of many tools that makes Ukraine’s campaign more successful.
…
Republican lawmakers are in favor of the move, and committee Chair Rep. Michael McCaul (R-Texas) said last week that cluster munitions “would be incredibly effective against the heavily fortified Russian defensive positions the Ukrainians must now breach.”
Congressional Democrats, however, aren’t in favor. This week, in a letter…14 Senate Democrats wrote to…Jake Sullivan that “the humanitarian costs and damage to coalition unity of providing U.S. cluster munitions would outweigh the tactical benefits, and urge the president not to approve such a transfer.”
Third news item
Bipartisan legislation to offer incentives on sanction evaders in the works:
U.S. Senators Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI) and James Risch (R-ID) and Representatives Joe Wilson (R-SC) and Dean Phillips (D-MN) today introduced the Sanctions Evasion Whistleblower Rewards Act, bipartisan, bicameral legislation that would protect national security by offering rewards for information leading to the arrest or conviction of sanctions evaders.
“Our bipartisan bill will incentivize the sharing of information to help apprehend dangerous Russian oligarchs,” said Whitehouse. “Providing rewards to informants can pay dividends in protecting our national security.”
“As we continue to ratchet up sanctions and pressure on malign actors, those actors are finding new ways to evade sanctions around the world,” said Risch. “This legislation will leverage the success of the State Department’s existing Rewards for Justice Program by expanding the program to include rewards for credible information on U.S. and UN sanctions evasion.”
Fourth news item
JVW writes: It’s as if they are actively trying to troll everyone who is not completely in thrall to the trans agenda. Do these people realize that this just brings more derision (and justifiably so) on their allies?:
A U.K. cervical-cancer fund, Jo’s Cervical Cancer Trust, has recommended “bonus hole” as a more inclusive term for “vagina.” A quick Google search defines “bonus hole” as “the vagina of a trans man.” Another alternative the group accepts is “front hole.” We’re to ask transgender men (a.k.a., females) which term they prefer.
Women keep taking the hit in these ongoing efforts at “inclusivity,” and it’s making me cranky.
Fifth news item
Well, if he means it won’t be a cringe-inducing circus without him, he’s right:
Former U.S. President Donald Trump said he might not participate in the Republican Party’s first 2024 election primary debate in August and may hold an alternative event, citing his lead in opinion polls and what he claims is the hosting network’s bias against him…called Fox News, which he has criticized for not covering his campaign events, a “hostile network” and said he saw little merit in debating candidates like former New Jersey governor Chris Christie who are far behind him in polling.
…
“We’ve had a lot of offers, whether it’s a rally or whether it’s an interview by somebody else,” he said. “Not to be braggadocious but the debate will not be a very exciting one if I’m not there.”
Sixth news item
Final report and recommendations from California’s Reparations Task Force on way to Gov. Newsom:
The task force has spent the last two years hearing testimony from academics, economists and other experts to gather evidence of the effects of slavery and to prove the ways in which government sanctioned policies continued to discriminate against Black people long after slavery was abolished…
Eligibility
The task force voted to recommend “only those individuals who are able to demonstrate that they are the descendant of either an enslaved African American in the United States, or a free African American living in the United States prior to 1900, be eligible for monetary reparations.”…
Compensation
The amounts each individual receives would be determined by the number of years they have resided in California for a minimum of six months of each year during a defined period of harm based on the laws and policies enacted at the time. The money would be given to every eligible recipient and no one would need to provide proof that they suffered direct harms. The task force also suggested the Legislature adopt an individual claims process to provide reparations for those who can prove particular harms.The pay models suggest:
Compensation for health disparities: $13,619 for each year of residency from 1850 to 2020. This figure was derived by comparing life expectancy between Black non-Hispanic and white non-Hispanic Californians.
Also included: [C]ompensation for mass incarceration and over-policing of African Americans, housing discrimination, changing existing law and adopting new polices to provide reparatory justice and ensure that the state does not repeat harms.
More details at the link.
Seventh news item
Ah:
The administration of Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) steered $92 million last year in leftover federal coronavirus stimulus money to a controversial highway interchange project that directly benefits a top political donor, according to state records.
The decision by the Florida Transportation Department to use money from the 2021 American Rescue Plan for the I-95 interchange at Pioneer Trail Road near Daytona Beach fulfilled a years-long effort by Mori Hosseini, a politically connected housing developer who owns two large tracts of largely forested land abutting the planned interchange. The funding through the DeSantis administration, approved shortly after the governor’s reelection, expedited the project by more than a decade, according to state documents.
Hosseini plans to develop the land — which includes a sensitive watershed once targeted for conservation by the state — into approximately 1,300 dwelling units and 650,000 square feet of nonresidential use, including an outdoor village shopping district. He has called the Woodhaven development, which has already begun construction, his “best project yet” and promised to pull out all the stops for its success.
Government documents obtained by The Washington Post through open-records requests show a steady relationship between DeSantis and Hosseini in recent years. The governor’s office occasionally received requests for DeSantis to attend events or support proposals from Hosseini, and DeSantis extended invitations to Hosseini for events in Tallahassee.
Hosseini helped DeSantis arrange a round of golf at Augusta National Golf Club in Georgia in 2018, according to the Tampa Bay Times. A year later, Hosseini donated a golf simulator that retails for at least $27,500 to the governor’s mansion, according to records previously obtained by The Post. In the 2022 campaign cycle, companies controlled by Hosseini gave at least $361,000 to political groups that benefited the DeSantis reelection campaign, according to state campaign finance records. Hosseini’s plane has been repeatedly used by DeSantis, according to a Post analysis.
Eighth news item
Getting serious about swatting:
As swatting incidents around the country increase, the FBI has created a national database to track them, according to new information from the law enforcement agency.
“In response to the national call on swatting, the FBI initiated the Virtual Command Center (VCC) known as the National Common Operation Picture (NCOP),” the FBI said in a statement to ABC News. The new database is a “collaborative effort between the FBI and law enforcement partners to track and create a real-time picture of swatting incidents,” the FBI says…
Since its inception in May 2023, the database has already tracked 129 swatting incidents around the country.
MISCELLANEOUS
Heh:
Have a great weekend! It’s going to be a hundred and hell degrees across the nation, so stay cool.
–Dana
Good morning!
Dana (560c99) — 6/30/2023 @ 7:11 amNeed a good conspiracy theory to start your day? Here’s a fun one.
https://www.kyivpost.com/post/18868
Probably too good to be true.
Appalled (1a7085) — 6/30/2023 @ 7:41 amRIP Oscar-winning actor Alan Arkin (89):
Rip Murdock (102247) — 6/30/2023 @ 7:51 amFirst News Item-The Swiss Only Care About The Swiss:
Watch the 1981 Oscar-nominated Swiss film The Boat is Full, which chronicles how Switzerland literally walled up train tunnels to prevent Jewish refugees fleeing the Nazi regime, condemning them to death in the concentration camps.
The Swiss collaboration with the Nazis is well documented, using the guise of neutrality which ends up enabling oppressive regimes. It is ironic that the country that hosts many international organizations that support those fleeing oppression does nothing to break that oppression.
Rip Murdock (102247) — 6/30/2023 @ 8:10 amFINALLY, the Supreme Court has done its job ans upheld the 1st Amendment. I hope Masterpiece and others can sue for damages due to the harm inflicted upon them by malicious private and government individuals.
NJRob (98da76) — 6/30/2023 @ 8:20 amSecond News Item-Finally:
Rip Murdock (102247) — 6/30/2023 @ 8:43 amAOC: “70% of Harvard’s legacy applicants are white … ”
Given that non-Hispanic whites constitute about 60% of the U.S. population, that’s not as wildly disproportionate as she’s implying.
To hear the rage-freakout from the left, you’d think that SCOTUS had ruled it acceptable to exclude black students systematically on the basis of race. People are calling the decision “racist” and claiming that the Court ruling says: “Black Americans do not count under the law.” It’s preposterous — and not just because the main beneficiaries will be Asian.
A person might argue that “a racially diverse student body is so important to education that we must treat people differently according to race,” or that “black students in general have had an educational disadvantage up to the time of applying for college, so we need to remedy the injustice at that point – and sustain different admissions standards by race for generations.” (The Bakke decision was 45 years ago.) Then let’s have a discussion.
But most of the left-wing response to the decision is basically: “If you believe in treating people equally regardless of race, you’re a racist.” Most people on the left aren’t reflecting on the condescension behind their assumption that the bar must be (permanently) kept lower for “people of color,” or else they have no chance at all.
Radegunda (6ddc2f) — 6/30/2023 @ 9:24 amEgalitarianism is dividing by zero. That’s why both sides can twist the “equal protection” pretzel into whatever shape suits them.
BTW, this comment is non-egalitarian. It’s only for people who know what you get when you divide by zero.
nk (2be170) — 6/30/2023 @ 10:04 amIt’s only for people who know what you get when you divide by zero.
All the answers at once.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 6/30/2023 @ 10:29 amAOC: “70% of Harvard’s legacy applicants are white … ”
What percentage of white admits are legacy or donor applicants?
Kevin M (2d6744) — 6/30/2023 @ 10:31 amWhat percentage of white admits are legacy or donor applicants?
It’s been reported that roughly 35% of slots in the freshman class are reserved for legacies at Harvard. Harvard has almost 2000 students in each freshman class, so if the 35% figure is correct then we’re looking at 700 legacies on average each year.
JVW (1ad43e) — 6/30/2023 @ 11:19 amRIP Oscar-winning actor Alan Arkin (89):
I really enjoyed him in Grosse Point Blank, playing the psychiatrist to John Cusack’s professional hitman character. He played the droll, deadpan comedy really well in that movie. Here’s a really good compilation of his scenes.
JVW (1ad43e) — 6/30/2023 @ 12:06 pmCross-Posted From Final Day of Court Term Open Thread:
More
While the particular circumstances of this case don’t involve a sympathetic defendant, the constitutional principles are important. This is good news.
Rip Murdock (102247) — 6/30/2023 @ 1:03 pmSad!
Rip Murdock (102247) — 6/30/2023 @ 1:11 pmNo lookalikes – this is nonsense – but it is clear that Putin thinks that there are things he does not know.
The split with Prigozhin is real, although at what point Putin realized that is another question. He couldn’t reach him on the phone and neither could the Belorussian president but the Belorussian president found a clever way around that. Prigozhin had posted a video of himself with some Russian and he called that Russian.
There were a number of double agents or leaks. Prigozhin’s plans to take the Russian defense minister hostage on a scheduled visit to Rostov-on-Don were found out and he found out that they had been found out.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 6/30/2023 @ 2:19 pmFrom last weekend’s open thread:
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/27/us/politics/irs-official-justice-dept-hunter-biden.html
Merrick Garland may have avoided perjury but what he said was very tricky. David Weiss’s legal authority is one thing – his staying within DOJ rules is another.
Here is more:
https://www.wsj.com/articles/merrick-garlands-cheap-talk-hunter-biden-fbi-investigation-irs-whistleblower-felony-charges-tax-470b46ac
Rigged to fail or to come as close as they plausibly could to letting Hunter Biden off.
Other questions: Why did Weiss wait until October 7, 2022 to tell his investigators that he did not have full authority to bring charges?
Why did the prosecutors in DC and California turn down the cases – why really? – and how much of an effort was made to get them to taake over the cases?
If Hunter Biden had to be prosecuted in DC or in California, why were charges brought in Delaware? Because his attorneys did not object, since that had the effect if immunizing him against any further tax charges?
BTW, the NYT confirmed only for California )although that’s the big one)
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 6/30/2023 @ 2:30 pmYou can’t read Twitter any more without creating an account?
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 6/30/2023 @ 2:33 pmDonald Trump had Operation Warp Speed
Joe Biden has:
This is what I mean:
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/26/health/covid-vaccines-nextgen.html
Sammy Finkelman (d007a3) — 6/30/2023 @ 2:37 pmhttps://www.wsj.com/podcasts/opinion-potomac-watch/was-the-hunter-biden-investigation-handled-improperly/291dfe09-dd24-49cc-b6e0-3dda54af5196
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 6/30/2023 @ 2:42 pmThere may be a superceding indictment of Donald Trump both in New Jersey (especially of the Miami judge harms the case) and in Miami. They may add documents counts so perhaps the Iran document may be included after all.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 6/30/2023 @ 2:44 pmA suggestion for the Democrats. That “donkey” symbol is obsolete. “Santa Claus” would be closer to the truth.
The jury is still out on the symbol for the GOP, although the elephant (in the middle of the room) might be accurate.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 6/30/2023 @ 3:52 pmvaccine development, after being shifted into high gear early in the pandemic, has returned to its slower and more customary pace….
The bureaucracy will not be denied. They are adamant about testing 21st century vaccines with 19th century methods, all the time thinking “Avoid all blame.”
Kevin M (2d6744) — 6/30/2023 @ 3:56 pmTrump Civil Litigation Watch:
………
Carroll’s “actions of wantonly and falsely accusing [Trump] on multiple occasions of committing rape constitute defamation per se, as [Carroll] accused Trump of rape, which clearly was not committed, according to the jury verdict[.]”
……….
“Due to [Carroll’s] repeated falsehoods and defamatory statements” made against Trump, he “has been the subject of significant harm to his reputation, which, in turn, has yielded an inordinate amount of damages sustained as a result,” says the counterclaim, filed Tuesday.
Trump says that Carroll “made these false statements with actual malice and ill will with an intent to significantly and spitefully harm and attack [Trump’s] reputation, as these false statements were clearly contrary to the jury verdict in [the case] whereby [Trump] was found not liable for rape by the jury.”
……….
……….(Carroll) attorney Robbie Kaplan said in the statement. “Four out of the five statements in Trump’s so-called counterclaim were made outside of New York’s one-year statute of limitations. The other statement similarly will not withstand a motion to dismiss. Trump’s filing is thus nothing more than his latest effort to delay accountability for what a jury has already found to be his defamation of E. Jean Carroll. But whether he likes it or not, that accountability is coming very soon.”
………..
I don’t see how the counterclaim gets past a dismissal under NY’s Anti-SLAPP law.
Rip Murdock (102247) — 6/30/2023 @ 3:58 pmThis is why I hate Trump’s use of Deep State, Establishment, etc., because he and his associates all reside in the same swamp.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 6/30/2023 @ 4:34 pmSusie Wiles works on Trump’s 2024 campaign and is co-chair of Mercury Public Affairs, which has taken millions of dollars in recent years from Chinese companies such as Yealink, Hikvision and Alibaba.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 6/30/2023 @ 4:34 pm
That’s okay, because she’s with Trump. 😉
norcal (8b5267) — 6/30/2023 @ 4:39 pmAnd our fentanyl will now be made by Harvard-trained chemists at Wuhan. Ivanka’s trademarks are the gift that keeps on giving.
nk (8c1a05) — 6/30/2023 @ 5:11 pmThe jury is still out on the symbol for the GOP, although the elephant (in the middle of the room) might be accurate.
Good one!
JVW (1ad43e) — 6/30/2023 @ 5:27 pmTrump Civil Litigation Watch II:
Rip Murdock (102247) — 6/30/2023 @ 5:48 pmLink to Judge Kaplan’s dismissal of Trump’s motion.
Rip Murdock (102247) — 6/30/2023 @ 5:51 pmRode my mtn bike up the hill in early afternoon. It was 72 on the road at my house and 3-4 miles later and some elevation gain over the fog layer it was a dry 108 road temperature
steveg (10ef87) — 6/30/2023 @ 6:16 pmsteveg (10ef87) — 6/30/2023 @ 6:16 pm
I share your preference for seeking a more comfortable temperature.
You think I’m joking…
norcal (8b5267) — 6/30/2023 @ 6:24 pmMore good news for 2024! Not content with enraging pro-choice women with abortion ruling and blacksnative americans and latinx with their affirmitive action ruling so they will crawl on hands and knees if they have to to get to the polls to vote out republicans. Now they have decided thats not enough lets enrage gays and young people with student loans so they will vote out republicans too! Which americans do they plan to enrage next?
asset (c2eed7) — 6/30/2023 @ 8:20 pmWe will see if net taxpayers realize they must show up to vote or not
steveg (10ef87) — 6/30/2023 @ 9:56 pmFor those who follow Ukraine and their defense against Russian imperialism on Twitter, Mr. Mylovanov is one of the better ones, and his assessment of Trump’s 24-hour peace deal is a good example.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 6/30/2023 @ 10:26 pmInteresting to watch France burn yet again with a combination of their own antifa and youths of unknown origin.
They took Heath Ledger’s Joker’s goals to heart. “Some just want to watch the world burn.”
NJRob (eb56c3) — 7/1/2023 @ 5:51 amNot that Trump’s speaking at a Klanned Karenhood event will affect his support from his devotee base, but the rest of the electorate may not look kindly.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/1/2023 @ 7:43 amA summary from the ADL noted their use of a Hitler quote in their newsletters, and there are “links between numerous Moms for Liberty chapters and extremist groups like the Proud Boys, Three Percenters, sovereign citizen groups, QAnon conspiracist, Christian nationalists, and in one case, with the founder of the AK-47-worshiping Rod of Iron Ministries church in Pennsylvania.”
‘Is Anyone Else’s Pornhub Not Working?’ Virginia Democrat Riled Up After Anti-Porn Law Gets Entire State Blocked by Site
nk (0aeb45) — 7/1/2023 @ 7:56 amPaul, I think MFL is a pretty awful group but my reading of their use of the Hitler quote was not in support of an idea of Hitler’s but rather calling their saying their enemies were doing what Hitler did. Resorting to calling your enemies “basically Hitler” is never a great look but it’s not on the same level as using a Hitler quote in a positive light.
Nate (1f1d55) — 7/1/2023 @ 7:59 amNate, they initially quoted Hitler without explanation or attribution. The proper response should’ve been an apology and probably a sacking, not an explanation to provide “context”.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/1/2023 @ 8:12 amPaul,
Do you ever put the effort in to call groups on the left names? Or is that only reserved for groups on the right?
NJRob (b4dfd1) — 7/1/2023 @ 8:32 amhttps://www.dailywire.com/news/bidens-feds-cut-through-razor-wire-placed-by-texas-authorities-to-let-illegals-into-u-s
Biden is aiding and abetting the invasion of the United States of America. That is treason.
NJRob (b4dfd1) — 7/1/2023 @ 8:36 amYes, and no, to answer your question. Lately, the bigger problem is the hardline Trumpist right-wing, IMO.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/1/2023 @ 8:59 amWhy do you not have a problem with Moms For Liberty?
It’s unclear whether Jack Smith followed this line of inquiry, but Trump made similar entreaties to AZ Gov. Ducey as he did with Raffensperger, which shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/1/2023 @ 9:07 amThey aren’t violent. They have a right to protest. Other than that, they aren’t worthy of being on my radar.
I am not retired and still need to earn my living.
NJRob (b4dfd1) — 7/1/2023 @ 9:09 amNo, it’s not.
Rip Murdock (102247) — 7/1/2023 @ 9:16 amUnfortunately Musk has blocked non-subscribers from accessing Twitter, so we cannot see your links.
Rip Murdock (102247) — 7/1/2023 @ 9:20 amMoms for Liberty did attribute the quote to Adolf Hitler, it was below the quote.
Rip Murdock (102247) — 7/1/2023 @ 9:25 amMrs. Montagu would be surprised to know that I’m retired, but good to know your “standard”.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/1/2023 @ 9:32 amI advise joining, at the very least for accessing the links. The place can be a cesspool or informative, depending on who you follow, and never click on “For You”, because that’s where Musk’s algorithm cesspool resides.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/1/2023 @ 9:34 amRussian Media Watch:
Sad!
Rip Murdock (102247) — 7/1/2023 @ 11:01 amAnother Open Window:
Rip Murdock (5a15dc) — 7/1/2023 @ 11:07 amSad!
Trump’s motion to transfer the case to federal court.
Rip Murdock (102247) — 7/1/2023 @ 11:31 amHigh-end Russian apartment buildings catering to the business and political elite must put a pretty high premium on ground-floor units.
JVW (c535be) — 7/1/2023 @ 12:09 pmRip,
Yes it is.
NJRob (944af5) — 7/1/2023 @ 12:27 pmhttps://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/article-4/
nk (0aeb45) — 7/1/2023 @ 7:56 am
There may be other similar services that are available.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/1/2023 @ 12:34 pmWhy do you not have a problem with Moms For Liberty?
Would you ban their speech? Should government pressure Twitter, Facebook and Snapchat to block them?
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/1/2023 @ 12:36 pm‘Ultimate Authority’
Related:
Some formatting changes.
The definition of a fishing expedition.
Rip Murdock (3aaf7e) — 7/1/2023 @ 12:40 pmThe Treason Clause is in Article III, Sec. 3, not Article IV. Fail!
Rip Murdock (744892) — 7/1/2023 @ 12:45 pmThe definition of a fishing expedition.
Not unlike the subpoena and subsequent release of Trump’s tax returns, which led nowhere.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/1/2023 @ 1:31 pmThe definition of a fishing expedition.
I guess you missed the Watergate hearings then. They fished, and they caught a few, like Alexander Butterflied.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/1/2023 @ 1:32 pmRip,
The requirement to defend the nation from invasion was in the clause I cited.
Fail!
NJRob (6dfef9) — 7/1/2023 @ 2:49 pmSection 4 of Article IV has nothing to do with “defending the nation from invasion.”
In Luther v. Borden (1849) the Supreme Court ruled that it was a political question left to Congress and the Executive branches to decided that it
Source
Section 4 applies to a military invasion of the states (which was a real threat in the early years of the Republic), not immigrants entering a state by crossing the border. There is no evidence that the Founders considered illegal immigration as an invasion; for one thing it wasn’t illegal to do so at the time. Article III, Section 3, is the only constitutional definition of treason.
Constitutional wishful thinking.
Rip Murdock (3aaf7e) — 7/1/2023 @ 3:53 pmNothing in Section 4, Article IV says “military” — you may read that into it, but it isn’t there. Stick to the text.
And nobdy cares what CJ Taney said. Lincoln sure didn’t.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/1/2023 @ 4:10 pmThere is no evidence that the Founders considered illegal immigration as an invasion
There is no evidence they considered a division of tanks to be an invasion either.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/1/2023 @ 4:11 pmIII, 3 defines treason as engaging in warfare against the United States, or supporting the aims of those that do, giving them aid and comfort. Either would do.
Biden, by enabling a mass movement of foreign persons into the border states is engaging in a form of warfare against them.
It might not be treason. But it also might be. Your certainty is misplaced.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/1/2023 @ 4:15 pmI didn’t and wouldn’t suggest any of that, Kevin. The point is that Trump didn’t have to speak at their event.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/1/2023 @ 4:16 pmFull results available as a download at link.
Related:
Rip Murdock (3aaf7e) — 7/1/2023 @ 5:06 pm@63-65:
Good luck making that argument in court, or during an impeachment. It’s entering MTG and Andy Biggs territory.
Rip Murdock (744892) — 7/1/2023 @ 5:10 pmAs far as I know Luther v. Borden hasn’t been overruled, despite what Lincoln thought of Taney.
Rip Murdock (3aaf7e) — 7/1/2023 @ 5:52 pmhttps://www.legislature.mi.gov/documents/2023-2024/billengrossed/House/pdf/2023-HEBH-4474.pdf
Another reminder how the left believes in nothing but power. They want to create a felony for freedom of speech. In their world “misgendering” someone is worthy of punishment like it is in England.
NJRob (eb56c3) — 7/1/2023 @ 6:57 pmMy Sentiments Exactly:
Rip Murdock (3aaf7e) — 7/1/2023 @ 6:59 pm@41 these are potential democratic voters. we don’t want them to get cut on the razor wire.
asset (e6d084) — 7/1/2023 @ 7:28 pm@71 whats wrong with power? its what rules the world.
asset (e6d084) — 7/1/2023 @ 7:30 pm@69 What they need is not dogma ;but a charismatic candidate. I like tulsi gabbard ;but probably for veep. Who has got the charisma?
asset (e6d084) — 7/1/2023 @ 7:35 pmThe point is that Trump didn’t have to speak at their event.
You expected decency? Why now?
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/1/2023 @ 10:05 pm@41 these are potential democratic voters. we don’t want them to get cut on the razor wire.
And, adhering to their cause, gives them aid and comfort.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/1/2023 @ 10:06 pmGood luck making that argument in court, or during an impeachment. It’s entering MTG and Andy Biggs territory.
1) Illegal entry is a violation of federal and Texas state law.
2) 18 USC 2383:
Maybe not “treason” exactly, but certainly insurrection, both against the United states, Texas and the laws of both.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/1/2023 @ 10:10 pm@njrob@71 The law you are linking is about the penalties for assaulting or battering a person, not just misgendering them. It does say that if you assault or batter someone for being transgender that it qualifies as a hate-crime.
Nic (230f8b) — 7/1/2023 @ 11:24 pmWhat do you think the word intimidate means to a leftist?
It specifically adds crimes for things that aren’t assaulting and battering.
NJRob (eb56c3) — 7/2/2023 @ 6:28 amLOL!
Rip Murdock (3aaf7e) — 7/2/2023 @ 8:09 amThe NYT has a piece on Hunter’s abandoned daughter, probably because they couldn’t hold out any longer.
The funny part is that his daughter not only gets monthly child support, but also a number of her dad’s paint-by-numbers works of “art”. Hunter’s baby mama is the daughter of a “rural gun maker” and her lawyer represented the Trump campaign, so we can guess her politics.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/2/2023 @ 8:21 amBTW, it’s a lie for Joe Biden and/or his people to claim he has six grandkids. Like it or not, the facts say seven.
Also, Hunter comes out as a complete schmuck in this tale, abdicating responsibility at every turn until forced into litigation. I’ll never vote for him, nor his enfeebled dad.
Stupid short term thinkers… they needed to look at that progeny the same way the Kennedy Shrivers viewed Arnold and the offspring. And put egg in the face of the Juanita Broaddricks and Tara Reades of the world.
urbanleftbehind (099a0c) — 7/2/2023 @ 8:31 am73 sshhh! But the ‘zolanos will be probably be slow-bake future Rs on a Marielito time frame (too long, 36-40 years, nearly 9 election cycles).
urbanleftbehind (099a0c) — 7/2/2023 @ 8:33 amAsset,
We are governed by laws. The Constitution first and foremost.
NJRob (fd5d62) — 7/2/2023 @ 9:19 am“Insurrection” can be defined as:
which doesn’t fit your argument. Nothing in Biden’s immigration policy fits that definition. In fact, the Supreme Court just this term acknowledged that the government has right to set enforcement priorities since Congress hasn’t provided the necessary funding to enforce immigration laws to the letter.
And if the illegal immigration situation at the border is an “invasion”, then Congress needs to authorize the US military to use deadly force against border crossers.
Rip Murdock (3aaf7e) — 7/2/2023 @ 9:25 amThe first written customer complaint was over 37 centuries ago. Some things don’t change.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/2/2023 @ 9:30 amhttps://www.francetvinfo.fr/faits-divers/adolescent-tue-par-un-policier-a-nanterre/val-de-marne-le-domicile-du-maire-de-lhay-les-roses-vandalise-son-epouse-hospitalisee_5925635.html
If this is accurate, France has entered a new phase of terrorism and horror. Trying to burn down Paris’s mayor’s home and causing his family to flee.
NJRob (fd5d62) — 7/2/2023 @ 9:46 amNot Ready for Prime Time:
Rip Murdock (3aaf7e) — 7/2/2023 @ 9:58 amthe act or an instance of revolting esp. violently against civil or political authority or against an established government
You deny that waves of illegal immigrants are acting against civil or political authority? Amazing.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/2/2023 @ 10:45 amWhen the Miami mayor was asked if his campaign would mention the Chinese minority, Suarez responded by asking, “What’s a Uyghur?”
He’s just acting out and seeking attention.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/2/2023 @ 10:47 amIt’s a very personal family matter and nobody’s business but the Bidens’.
nk (f592e8) — 7/2/2023 @ 11:06 amIt speaks to character, nk.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/2/2023 @ 11:35 amBTW, it’s a lie for Joe Biden and/or his people to claim he has six grandkids. Like it or not, the facts say seven.
Also, Hunter comes out as a complete schmuck in this tale, abdicating responsibility at every turn until forced into litigation. I’ll never vote for him, nor his enfeebled dad.
I’m sick and tired of hearing that Joe Biden is a “good man” and a “loving patriarch” and all of that. This sort of thing goes to show what a true horses’s rear-end he is. I once respected him for not exploiting the horrible death of his first wife and young daughter in a tragic car crash, but then I learned that he had been peddling a completely false narrative about the driver of the other vehicle being drunk at the time — cynically impugning the character of a guy who according to his daughters was haunted by that crash for the rest of his life, all to garner even more sympathy for an awful event. And I know it must be hard to lose your other son to cancer, but that gives Joe Biden no permission to lie about the circumstances, again for political reasons. And of course you have his history of baloney, balderdash, and bunkum, his general creepiness with women and girls, and his tetchy grouchiness and general oafishness.
Joe Biden is a real jerk.
JVW (1ad43e) — 7/2/2023 @ 11:37 amIt’s a very personal family matter and nobody’s business but the Bidens’.
I would be inclined to agree with that were it not for Team Biden’s incessant efforts to portray the President as a good family man and decent human being, which I just asserted he is not.
JVW (1ad43e) — 7/2/2023 @ 11:39 am@NJRob@80 Intimidate has a specific legal definition. Legally speaking it doesn’t mean “makes me feel bad.”
Nic (230f8b) — 7/2/2023 @ 11:41 amExcept that Biden has politically portrayed himself as all about family yet doesn’t even recognize the existence of his bastard grandchild. The hypocrisy seems pretty obvious to me.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/2/2023 @ 11:46 amI do wish Ms. Roberts and daughter all the best, but her family also went the political route by whom they chose for legal counsel.
Also, I’m not thrilled that grown sons and daughters of prominent political figures have become fair game in politics, but Hunter made a conscious choice to exploit his family’s name in exchange for big paychecks. On one side, I’m sympathetic about his drug addition, but on the other side he’s a grown man who made those choices.
Also, I’m not thrilled that grown sons and daughters of prominent political figures have become fair game in politics, but Hunter made a conscious choice to exploit his family’s name in exchange for big paychecks. On one side, I’m sympathetic about his drug addition, but on the other side he’s a grown man who made those choices.
Well said. I feel the same way.
I also objected when the Obamas would use Sasha and Malia for political purposes — Michelle while crusading about school lunches mentioned that she had had to get on the girls about eating junk food, and she was happy to discuss with the public how she and her husband had to keep on them to study hard and do their homework — yet when political opponents would ask a legitimate question such as “If the Obamas are so supportive of public school education, why have they chose to send both of their daughters to tony private schools?” that was considered to be “dragging the girls” into the political wars.
JVW (1ad43e) — 7/2/2023 @ 11:51 amWhy I’m not concerned about Hunter Biden’s deal:
The deal requires him to remain sober for the next couple of years, or he faces the felony gun charge. He will be unable to do that. Even in the face of known adverse results, an addict will always pick up unless they have a complete change of mental attitude. Which, given dad’s co-dependent coddling, he’s not come close to having.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/2/2023 @ 12:27 pm@99: Meanwhile W did his best not to involve his daughters in political nonsense, yet the left had no problem attacking them when they had brushes with the law typical of young adults.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/2/2023 @ 12:31 pmEvery crime is an insurrection, since they are acts “against civil or political authority” based on that standard.
Illegal immigrants crossing the border are not equivalent to a violent action against the government (aka “insurrection”), unlike the participants in January 6th.
Beyond blaming Biden for illegal migration, and since claim it’s a violent act against the government, what would you propose to stop it?
I look at what the law says, what the Supreme Court has said, etc. and form an opinion. I don’t engage in Constitutional fantasies.
Rip Murdock (3aaf7e) — 7/2/2023 @ 12:46 pmI’m sure the Secret Service also had something to do with that.
Rip Murdock (3aaf7e) — 7/2/2023 @ 12:49 pmThe public high school I graduated from was 1/8 mile from the Obama’s Chicago residence. Of course they were K-12 University of Chicago Lab Schoolers.
urbanleftbehind (40111d) — 7/2/2023 @ 12:56 pmVying for VP:
Rip Murdock (3aaf7e) — 7/2/2023 @ 1:05 pmQuinnipiac University Pennsylvania Poll 6/28/23
Rip Murdock (744892) — 7/2/2023 @ 1:25 pmI’m sure the Secret Service also had something to do with that.
Amy Carter attended public schools in Washington DC. Granted, those were earlier post-9/11 days, but could it really have been harder to monitor the Obama girls’ safety at, for example, the Benjamin Banneker Academy High School (how awesome would it have been to have the children of the first black President attend a school named for Benjamin Banneker?) than it was protecting Malia at Harvard or Sasha at the University of Michigan and USC?
And just think of the incongruity of having heavily armed Secret Service officers at a Quaker school.
JVW (1ad43e) — 7/2/2023 @ 1:35 pmThe DeSantis Trouble With Women: They Don’t Like Him
Rip Murdock (3aaf7e) — 7/2/2023 @ 1:48 pmAbortion bans like the one DeSantis signed in Florida are unpopular with many women.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/2/2023 @ 2:30 pmIn a hypothetical 2024 general election matchup between Biden and Trump, the race is a virtual dead heat among all registered voters with 47 percent RELUCTANTLY supporting Trump and 46 percent RELUCTANTLY supporting Biden.
FIFY.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/2/2023 @ 2:34 pmhttps://www.newsbusters.org/blogs/nb/alex-christy/2023/07/01/mystal-smears-thomas-mutilated-version-black-justice
This type of virulent racism is mainstreamed into leftist thought every single day.
NJRob (eb56c3) — 7/2/2023 @ 4:17 pmHeh! The light at the end of the tunnel is New Jersey? Okay, then!
nk (f592e8) — 7/2/2023 @ 4:23 pmAre people so desperate for someone, anyone, to call out Trump that they forget that Christie did run in 2016, that he was on the stage with Trump in the debates, and all he did was manoeuver to become Trump’s favorite girl? Kissing in public included?
nk (f592e8) — 7/2/2023 @ 4:30 pmAnyone else think Putin is throwing some cash at French anarchists (excuse me, I meant to say anti fascists)
steveg (545e33) — 7/2/2023 @ 4:50 pmTo me it would seem like a good investment as a million dollars can buy a lot of fireworks, fertilizer and diesel fuel.
This type of virulent racism is mainstreamed into leftist thought every single day.
John Paul Stevens quoted Cruikshank in his dissent in Heller. Cruikshank makes <Plessy look like a walk in the park, as it legitimatized lynching.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/2/2023 @ 5:16 pmFox News Poll 6/28/23
Top line and cross tabs.
Rip Murdock (3aaf7e) — 7/2/2023 @ 5:22 pmYou can say the same about Darling Nikki.
Rip Murdock (744892) — 7/2/2023 @ 5:27 pmSince Christie is the only candidate to do so (even at 3% his polling is 3x higher than Hutchinson), the answer is yes, unless you think no one should be calling Trump out.
Rip Murdock (3aaf7e) — 7/2/2023 @ 5:33 pmJust picking up the phone when a pollster calls makes a person a more likely “King Stork” than “King Log”.
nk (f592e8) — 7/2/2023 @ 5:35 pmI do say the same thing about Darjeeling Nikki. In fact, I say the same thing about every Republican running for any office. Christie was just the subject of the moment. They all have the Trump taint. Everyone of them.
nk (f592e8) — 7/2/2023 @ 5:41 pmhe was on the stage with Trump in the debates, and all he did was manoeuver to become Trump’s favorite girl?
I doubt they forget that, since Christie cops to it first thing.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/2/2023 @ 6:06 pmThis type of virulent racism is mainstreamed into leftist thought every single day.
I’ve said it before: Elie Mystal is Al Sharpton with a Harvard Law degree.
JVW (1ad43e) — 7/2/2023 @ 7:35 pmShe is confused. Justice Thomas cited Justice Harlan’s dissent in Plessy vs Ferguson:
DRJ (fd3827) — 7/2/2023 @ 8:18 pm@85 the lone ranger and tonto are surrounded by hostile indians. The lone ranger turns to tonto and says “were in trouble now! Tonto. Tonto replys what you mean “we” white man. Rosa parks thought differently and so do many of “us!” As Malcolm X said “by any means necessary!” Lexington green was not governed by laws. This is what gives my side the edge.
asset (0542d3) — 7/3/2023 @ 12:08 amAsset, I thought guys mellowed as they got older. How are you the exception?
norcal (8b5267) — 7/3/2023 @ 12:16 am@126 I have mellowed and a lot. Especially after I realized the world will get along just fine when I am gone.
asset (0542d3) — 7/3/2023 @ 12:32 amHere are some “real” patriotic songs that won’t be played on the 4th of july. Ohio, alabama, rockin in the free world, we can be together, why can’t we be friends, save the country and the ties they are a changing. Maybe born in the usa as the rednecks don’t understand the lyrics.
asset (0542d3) — 7/3/2023 @ 12:41 amMs. Amelina put her writing career on hold to document Russian war crimes, but she fell victim to a Putin war crime in Kramatorsk, the one where he blew up a pizzeria. There were vatniks at Instapundit trying to claim that it was a legitimate military target, despite the fact that the lives of four children were snuffed out.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/3/2023 @ 5:47 am@57
I don’t think so buddy.
https://hotair.com/jazz-shaw/2023/07/03/david-weiss-explanation-of-hunter-biden-investigation-confirms-what-we-knew-n562168
Read the whole thing.
This was an influence-peddling and money-laundering operation. And quite a blatant one.
The question remains, does anyone in DC have the honor and integrity to investigate this in good faith?
Its unfortunate, that it’s taking Republicans in Congress to push this.
whembly (5f7596) — 7/3/2023 @ 6:47 amMel Brooks had a scene in Blazing Saddles of Hunter Biden and the Republicans in Congress. Hunter is the one in the cowboy hat.
nk (272eae) — 7/3/2023 @ 7:13 amHeh! On further thought, make that “and the Republicans
nk (272eae) — 7/3/2023 @ 7:31 amin Congress“.Lexington green was not governed by laws. This is what gives my side the edge.
Yeah. Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot and the like are your heritage. Be proud.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/3/2023 @ 9:41 amEspecially after I realized the world will get along just fine when I am gone.
What did you think before then?
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/3/2023 @ 9:42 am22. Kevin M (2d6744) — 6/30/2023 @ 3:56 pm
Not 19th or early 20th century methods – use if insulin after its discovery was quick – or mid-20th century methods, like the polio vaccines – and they did make mistakes – but late 20th century methods.
They practically make it impossible for personalized medicine, They demand approval for diagnostic tests. The only thing not needing approval is new types of surgery. There’s good and there’s bad with that.
Sammy Finkelman (0653a4) — 7/3/2023 @ 10:09 amwhembly (5f7596) — 7/3/2023 @ 6:47 am
Maybe James Comer, although he has to deal with members of his committee majority who are not too interested in good faith.
he institution and possible backlash, gives some advantage to those who are interested in the truth and no more.
Sammy Finkelman (0653a4) — 7/3/2023 @ 10:13 amLOL! If anything there should be a joint House-Senate Select Committee investigation.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/3/2023 @ 12:58 pmComer is the one who has made wild accusations of multi-million dollar transfers to the President while at the same time acknowledging he doesn’t have proof.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/3/2023 @ 1:03 pmCase in point.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/3/2023 @ 1:05 pmThat Was Then, This Is Now:
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/3/2023 @ 1:13 pmThe fact that he acknowledged he didn’t have proof is an indication he’s is interested in the truth.
he had evidence – the FBI report. But it is all, very unlikely hearsay. Zlochevsky may have indeed claimed it/
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/3/2023 @ 2:44 pmComedy gold! If he was interested in the truth he would make his wild, unsupported accusations without evidence.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/3/2023 @ 4:14 pmCorrection:
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/3/2023 @ 4:16 pmNow protests over affirmitive action for rich white people. Legacy admissions. Look what happened to aunt becky without them.
asset (14ba77) — 7/3/2023 @ 4:41 pmPerhaps you would be more comfortable with the DeSantis border plan:
He also advocates closing the “Flores loophole, however, that is a federal court decree (Flores v. Reno). Congress can overturn the decree, but has in fact codified parts of it into law.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/3/2023 @ 6:07 pmRip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/3/2023 @ 6:07 pm
As long as there is a strong black market for drugs in the U.S., the cartels will find a way to get drugs here.
Of course, any politician who mentions complete legalization of drugs will crash and burn, because Americans don’t understand economics, and seemed to have learned no lessons from Prohibition.
The more the War on Drugs is waged, the higher the black market price. The higher the price, the more ruthless the cartels will be, and the more corrupt the Mexican government will become. And, as a bonus, users will have to commit more crime to get the money to pay for the drugs.
It’s one of those counterintuitive things. Saying “get tough on the drug trade” is ridiculous.
norcal (8b5267) — 7/3/2023 @ 6:37 pmWhat the “shoot first, don’t ask any questions” DeSantis plan fails to realize is that most illegal drugs are smuggled through US ports and airports.
Source
Rip Murdock (744892) — 7/3/2023 @ 7:40 pmhttps://www.dailywire.com/news/inflation-causes-fourth-of-july-cookout-items-to-hit-record-high-report
Have a blessed Independence Day free from government interference.
NJRob (eb56c3) — 7/4/2023 @ 5:38 amNext time were to traveling or thru Tennessee, we’re definitely going to the biggest gas station in the whole world.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/4/2023 @ 5:48 amHappy 4th, y’all. Our county may be all about snakes and sparklers, but we’re going to a Joe Dirt style whizbang.
Happy 4th, to all of you.
(I will be celebrating it by watching the local parade, which seems about the right size to me, and has a very high participation level. They begin with my favorite part, a children’s parade, allowing proud moms to show off their children, dressed appropriately.)
Jim Miller (7b1395) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:26 amEhh, Buccees is an inverted Meijer in terms of the gas sales:food+clothes retail sales ratio. It would be cool if you ran into Sydney Sweeney at that fireworks show.
urbanleftbehind (099a0c) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:29 amDamn you Robert Crimo for spooking half the towns in my county from doing anything today.
urbanleftbehind (099a0c) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:30 amSadly, the Federal government has already interfered in my celebration by banning cherry bombs, M-80s, and other fireworks.🧨😉
Rip Murdock (3aaf7e) — 7/4/2023 @ 10:13 amAs long as there is a strong black market for drugs in the U.S., the cartels will find a way to get drugs here.
After a long and arduous fight, federal authorities put an end to mass distribution of high-grade Oxycontin, only to see production Oxy replaced by fentanyl-laced counterfeits that are far more dangerous.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 10:30 ambanning cherry bombs, M-80s, and other fireworks.
Well, those are really just bombs. There are plenty of really dangerous fireworks you can still get.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 10:33 amJudge blocks U.S. officials from tech contacts in First Amendment case
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 10:35 amI’m interested in your thoughts about DeSantis’s border plan.
Also, since you apparently consider the illegal immigration at the border to be a national security threat, would you favor Congress allowing the military to use lethal force against them?
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 11:22 amI would like to see a trial on the merits.
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 11:24 amSo the government got the government to order the government not to talk to techies? Only in America.
nk (f269d2) — 7/4/2023 @ 11:44 amPlease explain how illegal immigration at this scale is not a national security threat?
steveg (a24ff1) — 7/4/2023 @ 11:50 amI don’t think it’s threatening the survival of nation, at best it’s a serious problem for the southwest border region.
Since you think it is a national security threat, would you favor Congress allowing the military to use lethal force against border crossers?
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 11:55 amI don’t think it’s threatening the survival of nation, at best it’s a serious problem for the southwest border region.
Which includes whole states, which are being invaded. A human wave doesn’t really need guns.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 12:48 pmI’m interested in your thoughts about DeSantis’s border plan.
DeSantis is trying to out-demagogue Trump. I’ve never been a DeSantis fan. On a scale of 1 to 10, he’s a 3. Still, a 3 is better than a 1.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 12:50 pmSo, I just found out that the progressive cabal that has taken over my state has not only eliminated cash bail (leading to criminals arrested with 5 previous charges pending, and released again), but they’ve eliminated qualified immunity for police, prosecutors and judges.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 12:53 pmAside from your personal opinion about DeSantis, are there any aspects of his plan you like? Also, since this is a national security issue, do you favor impeaching Biden over it?
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 12:55 pmAgain, what policies would you like to see implemented to counter this “national security” threat?
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 12:57 pmYou don’t use military force against a needle in a haystack, but you sure can use a magnet developed by the military if they’ve got one.
The smuggling routes are owned by cartels. Human smugglers, drug smugglers are 100% cartel owned and operated subsidiaries that work together to overwhelm and confuse border security by making them look for a needle in a pile of needles. We don’t use military force to solve the problem at the border because we value human life and honor the lives of the human shields. Because I feel like we don’t know how to stop interconnected Chinese and Mexican players and their smuggling routes without kinetically welding the needles into molten form doesn’t mean it is not a national security threat and doesn’t mean the military can not be useful. When we use the word military, I tend to think explosions and some selective things can go boom and I would sleep just fine, but the DoD does cyber warfare well, it tracks shipments well, the Treasury is great at taking other peoples money, so sending in a Marine Expeditionary Unit is the military force of the very last resort.
Side note: I think the Israeli dilemma in West Bank and Gaza shows how force would be portrayed in any US intervention into Mexico. There will always be dead babies and wailing mothers at every scene….
steveg (a24ff1) — 7/4/2023 @ 12:59 pmRip
Do you live in the SW border region?
steveg (a24ff1) — 7/4/2023 @ 1:03 pmIn light of the SC decision in US v. Texas last month, I wonder how Missouri and Louisiana met their Article III standing threshold.
My guess is that the injunction will be overturned based on lack of standing.
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 1:13 pmYes.
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 1:16 pmAs you noted, DOD and Treasury are all ready doing those things; and Israel has decided that the pictures of dead bodies are worth it (or they just ban journalists).
It’s become an article of faith among Republicans to use military force against the cartels, both on the campaign trail and among influential members of Congress.
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 1:31 pmDo you think the cartels would retaliate by conducting bombings and assassinations in United States, much as they do in Mexico?
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 1:34 pmI don’t think that Border Patrol agents should be shot at with impunity. I think it should be made very clear to Mexico that if our people take fire or even rocks from across the border, we reserve the right to defend ourselves. Doesn’t have to be every time, but am fine with telling Mexico that they can solve this themselves by simply enforcing their laws against the most difficult of their criminals. It is easy to put Tio Julio in prison for carry a rifle outside, tough to enforce it against the cartels. If DeSantis were to become President, laid the legal framework out and some cartel people died, I would not lose sleep, but would be aware that we might be out on slippery ledge where we have stepped away from normal diplomacy
Hernandez v. Mesa doesn’t authorize force, but realizes that deadly force occurs during border incidents, incidents the majority of the court sees as matters of national security and a Presidential concern.
Justice Samuel Alito, who wrote the opinion, said the deadly incident is a matter of national security, which is under the purview of Congress or the president. Those branches alone, he said, possess the power “to authorize the award of damages for injuries inflicted outside our borders.”
“A crossborder shooting affects the interests of two countries and, as happened here, may lead to disagreement. It is not for this Court to arbitrate between the United States and Mexico, which both have legitimate and important interests at stake and have sought to reconcile those interests through diplomacy,” Alito said.
This was the Mexican take on the incident during which there was some rock throwing.
steveg (a24ff1) — 7/4/2023 @ 1:46 pmHernandez Guereca was a secondary student in Juarez.
“The young man was not armed,” said Sergio Belmonte, Ciudad Juarez spokesman. “He did not have the physical size to threaten anyone. The aggression (by the U.S. agent) is evident.” Belmonte said Hernandez was shot in the head.
“My people have spoken to his family. His dad says he was a straight-A student. His secondary school even sent him on an academic trip because of his good grades,” Mayor Jose Reyes Ferriz said.
Happy Birthday to actress Eva Marie Saint (99). Oldest living Academy Award winner (Best Supporting Actress in 1951 for On the Waterfront, her screen debut) and one of the last remaining stars from the Golden Age of Hollywood. She was married to her husband for 56 years before his passing.
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 1:52 pmIf you really want to dissuade rock throwing or shootings across the border, Congress should authorize the Border Patrol and National Guard to not only return fire, but conduct hot pursuits into Mexican territory.
Rip Murdock (744892) — 7/4/2023 @ 1:56 pmOf course we are talking about a problem much bigger than rock throwing, it is how to stop the human and drug trafficking across the border. Which is why the Republicans are all in on sending troops into Mexico.
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 1:59 pmOf course we did that once before, and not to successfully.
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 2:07 pmRip
I wrote that last post before I read your recent post: do I believe the cartels would assassinate and bomb much as they do in Mexico?
Yes
Sometimes it is better to get on with a fight rather than slipping it again. I think cartels are very corrosive. They thrive on corruption, they create/operate black markets, they normalize under the table transactions. One of the reasons prisons in CA rehabilitate so few is the influence of the cartels within the system all the way down to the juvenile level. People need to see that the cartels are not all powerful, they bleed, and they are not accepted. If local agencies do not have the will of the local politicians and can’t do it, people will opt for the feds and eventually that will need to be be large scale paramilitary because the cartels are not going to back down.
steveg (a24ff1) — 7/4/2023 @ 2:08 pmOr we can give up and adopt the clearly broken Mexican system
Since we have tried everything that we can do on our own territory, I guess occupying the Mexican side of the border is the only option.
Rip Murdock (744892) — 7/4/2023 @ 2:23 pmAgain, what policies would you like to see implemented to counter this “national security” threat?
In a vacuum? Nearly every problem Los Angeles has (other than its politicians) would be solved by sending all the illegals back to Mexico since “overcrowding” is the root cause of congested roads, sky-high rents and rampant homelessness. Of course, this would create other problems, such as civil conflict.
How about” “We’re full up. Until we can sort out those we have, no new entrants. None, not for any reason.”
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 2:41 pmThe problem — and why they keep coming — is that our resolve is weak and our exceptions many.
In the end, we need to have a formal treaty with Mexico (and possibly other Central American countries) that formalizes entry to the US, makes Mexico responsible for controlling it, and provides US citizens with reciprocal rights in Mexico, such as free movement, owning property and equality before the law.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 2:46 pmOne of the problems that Mexico has with cartels is that members of their leadership are floating on drug money. So, a question:
Let’s say the the US military is called upon to smash the cartels with brute force, as we did with ISIS. Would they win, or would the cartel’s corruption spread to our leadership as well? Has it already?
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 2:54 pmAmong the lessons learned via watching the Israeli’s is “Hot pursuits are not a great idea.” Your link to the punitive expeditions illustrates that as well. But quick question since you brought it up
Was the US right to pursue Pancho Villa? I think so. The US had an obligation in its contract with citizens to do so. The fact that we didn’t execute the punitive expeditions well and get favorable results does not mean we should not have tried.
I do not think anyone serious actually wants to occupy the Mexican side of the border for longer than an hour or two but diplomacy has failed to get a result since, well, Pancho Villa and here we are.
The Israeli’s use a unit called Musta’ribeen for undercover military work in Palestinian areas. We probably have DEA, ATF agents doing similar work minus the kidnappings. Mexico can avoid all of this by simply enforcing their own laws. They love to enforce firearms laws on regular citizens, but let the cartels roam around armed in trucks with a .50 mounted in the bed. There are plenty of captured russian and iranian made 4-5km stand off anti vehicle munitions ATGM’s in Ukraine that eventually will make their way to people with cash and cartels definitely have cash.
steveg (a24ff1) — 7/4/2023 @ 3:00 pmAs for DeSantis’s plan … it’s palpable nonsense. The only thing about birthright citizenship that needs addressing is birthright tourism — fly into LAX, have a baby at UCLA, and then fly home. Birthright citizenship should be reserved to those intending to immigrate and become US residents. That they do so illegally does not reflect a lack of that intent.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 3:00 pmThe main problem with creating a buffer zone in Mexico (besides the terrible press) is that it solves nothing. You then have to deal with those encroaching on your border zone. So you need a bigger buffer. Etc.
The best plan is to regulate movement across the border by treaty, with shared responsibility, reciprocal rights and tax agreements.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 3:07 pmI’ve asked this before about states and standing: If the Constitution is a contract among states for Union, why don’t states have standing to insist it be followed?
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 3:09 pmArgument against punitive expeditions by US Military
https://mwi.usma.edu/half-measures-just-dont-work-case-bringing-back-punitive-expedition/
Given that rogue states are often dominated by authoritarian parties or individuals, a sharp divide exists between the regime and the populace, and this divide heavily influences how we conceptualize the enemy. In these instances, the populace is largely viewed as the victim and the enemy is narrowly identified as the regime’s leadership and its security apparatus. Under such conditions, punishing the regime without compounding the suffering of the already victimized populace can prove exceptionally difficult, and, when large segments of society and its requisite infrastructure are ethically off limits, there is little room left to punish. Strategists must also carefully assess whether a punitive expedition will galvanize an already divided society, strengthening the regime’s popularity by bringing the people and the party together under shared hardship and a common enemy
Argument for punitive expeditions
https://mwi.usma.edu/bringing-back-punitive-expedition/
As John Lewis Gaddis points out, connecting the means to the ends is difficult but vital. This ability must be in the military strategist’s intellectual toolkit. Including a punitive expedition into the proposed range of military responses to an enemy action can satisfy the need to act relatively swiftly and can assist in crafting a policy end within the ability of the applied means to achieve. A punitive expedition does not close the door on other options. A punitive expedition as a response option is also not a substitute for a strategy. But it can fit well into the conditions around which policy and strategy are developed and refined as conditions change—and strategists know conditions will change.
The narrative accompanying action must also be considered as a part of both the government policy and the supporting strategy. Playing well in Peoria is important, but a consideration of how the narrative plays in Paktia province and Paris must also be incorporated into both thinking and action. As Lt. Gen. Eric Wesley suggested during the 2019 Association of the US Army convention, whoever wins the narrative of the first battle may well win the war.
The purpose of the punitive expedition is to act with violence and return to home station. The linkage to policy is straightforward as execution of these types of expeditions will serve to demonstrate that the United States will reach out and take action to destroy a foe who threatens vital national interests and American lives. In ungoverned spaces, a punitive expedition is measured, focused, and not open-ended. A punitive expedition must act in coordination with diplomatic and informational efforts, each reinforcing the other. Indeed strategists and planners must bear in mind the political object irrespective of the development of use-of-force options.
steveg (a24ff1) — 7/4/2023 @ 3:19 pmhttps://news.yahoo.com/arizona-attorney-general-kris-mayes-140030478.html
Leftist Arizona Attorney General declares on the anniversary of our nation’s birth that she will ignore the law and the Constitution and continue to illegally discriminate against those exercising their constitutional rights… and she damns the Supreme Court in the process.
NJRob (eb56c3) — 7/4/2023 @ 3:27 pmI was being too flippant by saying “I do not think anyone serious actually wants to occupy the Mexican side of the border for longer than an hour or two” when clearly it could be days and even weeks.
steveg (a24ff1) — 7/4/2023 @ 3:31 pmI think we should be and probably are on the Mexican side of the border all day every day. We are reaching a point where we need to apply more and different leverage because what we are doing now has not yielded good enough results
@189 Wasn’t this tried at columbus new mexico in 1916? Lt didn’t end well. You could ask gen. pershing about that.
asset (54b9e4) — 7/4/2023 @ 3:37 pm@188 GOOD! Az getting better all the time! Thanks latinx birthrate! Over 100 latinx kids turn 18 everyday in az and they have voter ID’s. If you ad dreamers its 130 a day.
asset (54b9e4) — 7/4/2023 @ 3:40 pm@164 seems AOC is more popular in your state then conservatives. She is the future conservatives are the past
asset (54b9e4) — 7/4/2023 @ 3:45 pmOur leadership is floating on all types of money and I am certain we have people who are beholden to cartels. The main saving grace is that people in craven “leadership” are not limited to one, two or three streams of revenue and if they are shrewd, will avoid cartel money
steveg (a24ff1) — 7/4/2023 @ 4:02 pmPershing is still dead, so no
steveg (a24ff1) — 7/4/2023 @ 4:03 pmMy only qualm about this ruling is whether US counterintelligence is hindered against foreign bad actors.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/4/2023 @ 4:07 pmMr. Theiner has a thread on the Ukrainian counteroffensive. The lack of airpower means they have to attrite using other tactics.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/4/2023 @ 4:30 pmI think it was supposed to stop the establishment of a state religion, and from denying free exercise to the heretics who criticized it’s state support
steveg (a24ff1) — 7/4/2023 @ 5:14 pmPaul,
steveg (a24ff1) — 7/4/2023 @ 5:21 pmMr. Theiner seems correct in his assessment of need to bait Russians heavy equipment forward. One question that remained was how much is Ukraine losing in return. Even noting all the new equipment and recently trained brigades still due to arrive on the battlefield, I have questions that only action will show the answer to
We are reaching a point where we need to apply more and different leverage because what we are doing now has not yielded good enough results
We saw the quality of people, all 376 of them, who are doing “what we are doing now” at the Uvalde school shooting.
nk (567aa1) — 7/4/2023 @ 5:21 pmThey found cocaine in the West Wing. Of the White house. How are you going to curb the insatiable hunger this country has for recreational drugs? With so many people claiming it as a normal thing and an inalienable right?
nk (567aa1) — 7/4/2023 @ 5:53 pmThe Mexican response has been that America is responsible for the cartels because of its demand for drugs. I considered that to be decidedly unhelpful. Helpful would have been to agree we both have a problem and we need to help each other. I think it boils down to the billions of dollars the drug trade brings into Mexico.
steveg (a24ff1) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:16 pmWe get video of Hunter smoking crack and driving 172MPH on the road to Las Vegas, then we find out it was probably his cocaine in the WH Library
steveg (a24ff1) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:19 pmUnlike a contract between parties that allows one or the other to terminate the contract, there is nothing in the Constitution that allows a state to terminate their participation. Once a state agrees to join, they must stay in.
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:21 pmseems AOC is more popular in your state then conservatives. She is the future conservatives are the past
That’s what your side said in 1933, too.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:30 pmMy only qualm about this ruling is whether US counterintelligence is hindered against foreign bad actors
They have their own ways of manipulating opinion on the Internet.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:31 pmEven noting all the new equipment
Which is that? We promise stuff, but we are really not very good at delivering it.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:32 pmHow are you going to curb the insatiable hunger this country has for recreational drugs?
We cannot even keep drugs out of prisons. That should give one pause.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:33 pmUnlike a contract between parties that allows one or the other to terminate the contract, there is nothing in the Constitution that allows a state to terminate their participation. Once a state agrees to join, they must stay in.
That’s a non sequitur.
Suing in federal court to require the constitution be followed is a bit different than secession. It’s the civil way to deal with disputes.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:37 pmIf the Constitution is a contract, what provision allows a state to compel specific performance?
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:44 pmOnly a Trump-appointed judge would not have kicked these wingnuts out of his courtroom.
What’s next? A lawsuit by the street gangs to keep the neighborhood watch from talking to the police?
nk (567aa1) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:44 pmIf the Constitution is a contract, what provision allows a state to compel specific performance?
What provision says they can’t. There’s a judiciary for handling disputes. Is it impossible to conceive that a state might dispute an action of the federal government? Not everything is non-justiciable.
Suppose, for example, Congress passed a tax directly on border states, to cynically provide funding for immigrants. How would anyone sue to prevent this tax from being assessed even though Congress does not have that power?
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:51 pmOnly a Trump-appointed judge would not have kicked these wingnuts out of his courtroom.
Why are they wingnuts? OK, maybe they are but the first amendment actually protects wingnuts. They argue that the government is censoring speech by proxy. The judge saw enough evidence to say “maybe they are” and issued a TRO pending a hearing. Are you actually claiming that individuals do not have standing to pre3vent their speech from being censored by government action, even if it’s indirect?
I will point out that 3 Supreme Court justices are Trump-appointed. You need to put down the Blue pills.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:55 pmWhat’s next? A lawsuit by the street gangs to keep the neighborhood watch from talking to the police?
If the neighborhood watch is asking the police to arrest people on the BASIS of what their graffiti said, then yes.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 6:57 pmArticle III limits the judicial power to cases and controversies, which require someone to suffer a harm by someone’s unlawful conduct. There is no authority to sue to compel specific performance by the government.
Texas and Louisiana couldn’t demonstrate that harm in their recent immigration lawsuit, and Texas hasn’t been able to demonstrate harm in other cases, such as the election lawsuit against Pennsylvania in 2020 and in its challenges to Obamacare
Last month’s immigration case has a good description of what states need to meet standing requirements.
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:00 pmSo you would have courts assume authority that is not based on the Constitution?
Rip Murdock (744892) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:05 pmA Trump appointed judge also said there was enough evidence to ban Mifepristone.
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:08 pmHere’s one of those headlines you home never to see in your local paper:
It’s news that he was not released on his own recognizance. All he did was murder someone in a movie theater because “he was in my seat.” With a gun that was illegally carried, and had been modified to fire continuously. He had started a fight by dumping popcorn on the victim’s wife, and then claimed self defense when he emptied the clip into a crowded theater, killing the husband.
https://www.abqjournal.com/news/theater-shooting-suspect-to-stay-jailed/article_f27a5614-19ec-11ee-8627-ab08c41310e2.html
But he was a Latinx, so asset will take his side. Never mind that the victim was also Hispanic.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:10 pm*hope
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:10 pmA Trump appointed judge also said there was enough evidence to ban Mifepristone.
I guess that damns them all then. This even stretches to get to “guilt by association.” The rules don’t allow me to say what I actually think of this argument.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:12 pmSo you would have courts assume authority that is not based on the Constitution?
It’s implicit in the contract. As much as “judicial review” anyway.
And, again, you seem to rely a lot of “guilt by association” and other fallacies. That the TX vs PA suit was nonsense does not mean that all suits are nonsense. I presume you know that, but you write the words anyway.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:15 pmI’m empathetic to Hunter. People like me will now automatically assume the SS is running interference for him, we’ll believe the Fire department before we do the SS, and if there is cocaine found in the WH we will immediately figure it was Hunter already violating conditions of his plea deal and of course the SS is lying about it for him.
steveg (a24ff1) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:16 pmSomeday I hope to be a better person
As a matter of fact, I do think that Trump’s Supreme Court appointees are second-raters. All three of them together would not make one Scalia.
But the District Court appointees are even less than that. Blue slip specials with the right politics, the right connections to local Republican organizations, and the right contributions to Republican campaigns.
nk (2cd901) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:20 pmIt was just another example of a state lacking standing because Texas couldn’t demonstrate a particularized injury.
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:21 pmIf the Constitution is a contract, what provision allows a state to compel specific performance?
It’s not compelling performance that is usually the issue (although complete inaction in the face of an invasion is pretty raw), but preventing actions that are prohibited.
As it stands in the immigration situation the real problem is that there is no functioning immigration law. None. It is all the ruler’s whim now.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:26 pmIt was just another example of a state lacking standing because Texas couldn’t demonstrate a particularized injury.
Are you asserting that TX cannot demonstrate an injury with lightly-fettered immigration contrary to law?
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:27 pmNot sure what you mean by “guilt by association.” States, like everyone else who died in federal court, need to demonstrate a particularized injury to themselves.
Thems are the rules, whether you like them or not. Everything else is constitutional fantasy camp.
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:27 pmBut the District Court appointees are even less than that. Blue slip specials with the right politics, the right connections to local Republican organizations, and the right contributions to Republican campaigns.
NOW you have standards? The list of hacks is extensive.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:31 pmThe Supreme Court, voting 8-1 last month, seemed to think so.
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:31 pmNot sure what you mean by “guilt by association.”
Obviously.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:32 pmThe Supreme Court, voting 8-1 last month, seemed to think so.
And you agree?
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:33 pmI repeat: As it stands in the immigration situation the real problem is that there is no functioning immigration law. None. It is all the ruler’s whim now.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:33 pmSo, when people quote “The Rule of Law”, on immigration I roll my eyes.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/4/2023 @ 7:34 pm@157
So long as there’s clear Rules of Engagement, I’m okay with this.
Illegal immigration and smuggling is happening at the border because there’s no real deterrence. Often times, the Border Control just sit back and watch their surveillance cameras on obvious smugglers doing nothing due to assets being pulled to handle the illegal immigrant surge.
whembly (5f7596) — 7/5/2023 @ 7:23 am@165
He should absolutely be impeached.
It’s way beyond a “policy disagreement” and well into “derelection of duty to uphold the law”.
whembly (5f7596) — 7/5/2023 @ 7:25 am@176
I’m against “sending troops into Mexico” to “take care of the cartel problem”.
That’s a full scale invasion, and lets face it, it won’t work. We don’t have the stomach to conquer Mexico, because that’s what it would take to stop it via the “send the troops in”. We would have to institute something similar to the Marshall Plan like we did to Japan post-WW2.
But, we sure af need to be more aggressive with the Mexican government, more intelligence operations, build the f’n wall, pass domestic laws to discourage illegal immigration and actually ENFORCE the laws on the books.
whembly (5f7596) — 7/5/2023 @ 7:31 amGiven the news about cocaine being found, now Hunter and Jill have something in common: They both blew a little dope in the White House. Ba-dum…dum.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/5/2023 @ 8:29 amHe the “f” did that get into the whitehouse?
Tour folks has to leave their belonging in designated area AND you have to go through security that has trained dogs.
whembly (5f7596) — 7/5/2023 @ 8:34 amAs I agree with the Supreme Court’s approach to standing, yes. A generalized impact is not justiciable. Congress could change the rules on standing if it wished, but has failed to do so.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/5/2023 @ 8:50 amTour folks has to leave their belonging in designated area AND you have to go through security that has trained dogs.
I’d be betting on the VP, assuming they ever let her into the WH.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/5/2023 @ 8:52 amAs I agree with the Supreme Court’s approach to standing, yes. A generalized impact is not justiciable
And yet states often sue corporations for things that have a generalized impact, such as claiming that tobacco products, or oxycodone, caused their health costs to rise. But they cannot sue the federal government saying that unfettered immigration caused the same thing.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/5/2023 @ 8:57 amCuld I see the hands of those who thing that the Rule of Law prevails wrt immigration?
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/5/2023 @ 8:58 amI wish I could spell.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/5/2023 @ 8:59 amLacking The Courage of Their Convictions:
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/5/2023 @ 9:06 amThe states that sue corporations in federal court need to prove impacts on their governments (such as higher Medicaid costs).
Personally I don’t think states should be able to file lawsuits against private corporations.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/5/2023 @ 9:11 amHere’s the WaPo description of where the cocaine was found:
I’d have been worried, on seeing white powder, that it was anthrax.
Jim Miller (f2956e) — 7/5/2023 @ 9:11 amThe Wild Bunch needs impeachment so they can to to their districts and say they’ve been effective, even though they haven’t brought home any bacon or served any constituent needs.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/5/2023 @ 9:14 amThe states that sue corporations in federal court need to prove impacts on their governments (such as higher Medicaid costs).
You just repeat half of what I said, as if I hadn’t said it, and ignore the other half.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/5/2023 @ 9:16 amYour comment said:
I replied saying they needed to prove impacts on their governments, which is a specific impact.
I ignored the rest of your comment because we have already discussed it.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/5/2023 @ 9:20 amI think that states should be able to sue anyone for any tort they’ve experienced. I don’t think they should be able to sue for wrongs done their citizens if private class-action suits are possible.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/5/2023 @ 9:21 am@248: *Sigh*
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/5/2023 @ 9:21 amIf someone believes that the illegal immigration crisis is a an “invasion” under Article IV, Section 4 of the Constitution, impeachment is the only answer (since the states cannot compel enforcement).
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/5/2023 @ 9:58 amPutin’s personal security measures are, uh, a little isolating.
Paul Montagu (8f0dc7) — 7/5/2023 @ 10:22 amPutin is also clear not to punish people he purges too much – trying to be more like Khrushchev than Stalin – so that people will not be too afraid of him. Now this applies to people in his entourage who may have friends he left in positions
Sammy Finkelman (d007a3) — 7/5/2023 @ 1:04 pmhttps://www.nydailynews.com/opinion/ny-edit-congress-bill-migrants-labor-economy-biden-house-senate-reagan-20230705-5l4v6adk5ff7xkbtb2eqvajsx4-story.html
https://www.nydailynews.com/opinion/ny-oped-a-better-way-to-handle-migrants-20230629-clsavesmbnct5nesnmf65vjoai-story.html
Sammy Finkelman (d007a3) — 7/5/2023 @ 1:24 pmAs enforcement gets tougher, things like this happen:
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/16/world/europe/greece-migrant-boat-disaster.html
The boats are rickety because they have prevented people from boarding safe boats. Many many opeople will have to die before this stops, or rather the numbers go down further. Going down by 90% is not enough for them.
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/01/world/europe/greece-migrant-ship.html
Greece didn’t want to get stuck with the, Thy may have even have caused the capsizing by trying to tow the boat (avoiding taking people off the ship, which would have legal consequences.)
The NYT gives a sort of humanitarian motive for acting the way they did:
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/5/2023 @ 1:37 pmJim
On anthrax, there has been a vaccination for this since 2016, but it is not available to the general public. My guess is Biden has been vaccinated
Novichok? Very Russian, but excellent for misdirecting blame toward Putin
steveg (7b44ac) — 7/5/2023 @ 1:48 pmHi Sammy
Putin gave himself a birthday present:
steveg (7b44ac) — 7/5/2023 @ 1:55 pm“the celebrated investigative journalist, Anna Politkovskaya fell suddenly ill and lost consciousness after drinking a cup of tea while flying to the Russian city of Beslan during the school siege there. She survived, but was shot dead two years later, on Putin’s birthday.”
https://www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/origins-immigration-border-crisis-asylum-biden
or maybe this for free link:
https://www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/origins-immigration-border-crisis-asylum-biden?check_logged_in=1&utm_medium=promo_email&utm_source=lo_flows&utm_campaign=registered_user_welcome&utm_term=email_1&utm_content=20230705
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/5/2023 @ 2:01 pmUkrainian intelligence is said to say that Putin has ordered the murder of Yevgeny Prigozhin — but he is no hurry about it.
They were actually trying to take over the Wagner Group or supplant it before the mutiny or whatever it was. There were other militias set uo, one of them was run by Gazprom. Now the Wagner Group’s offices have been taken over by others, while in Syria and Africa, people closer to Putin are trying to run the group
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/5/2023 @ 2:09 pmOne thing that went on with Medicaid is that states are paying HMOa for people who have other insurance. Medicaid used too be fee for service, so if someone was getting health care from other places they didn’t use it.
Theiretically there are clawbacks, and people can indeed be sued. The amount sued for is trmendous – $15,000 a year in New York State – but the settlement amount is small.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/5/2023 @ 2:13 pmIf someone believes that the illegal immigration crisis is a an “invasion” under Article IV, Section 4 of the Constitution, impeachment is the only answer (since the states cannot compel enforcement).
They can vote in Trump, thinking he will root out the illegals with the Army and send them all packing.
More sanely, they can vote for another GOP candidate to beat Biden, then attempt to solve the immigration problem more holistically.
But the best way to get Biden out of office comes in November 2024. If you believe it’s an invasion, and you put that in front of all other things, then you vote for whoever is running for the GOP.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/5/2023 @ 2:20 pmDeSantis is causing problems for business in Florida (not so much for migrants who are sometimes moving to other states like North Carolina)
https://www.wsj.com/articles/migrant-workers-flee-florida-as-new-immigration-law-takes-effect-94796abf
Why should anyone think they could avoid problems by not hiring non-citizens, which the Florida law does not forbid, and the 1964 Civil Rights Act forbids avoiding?
Now why do they say they support documentation? They don’t, or at least when they say that they mean they want Congress to authorize it.
https://abcnews.go.com/US/undocumented-workers-face-uncertainty-immigration-law-takes-effect/story?id=100452861
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/5/2023 @ 2:25 pmGreg Kelly said (in another context) that Governor DeSantis has a cartoonish view of MAGA people.
DeSantis know that nobody in the Republican Party dares to argue in favor of not enforcing the law – but when it comes time to vote, I don’t think people affected will be happy. (they may be a minority, but people who want all laws enforced to the hilt are also a minority
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/5/2023 @ 2:28 pm263. Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/5/2023 @ 2:20 pm
DeSantis is out-Trumping Trump.
His sole advantage is that nobody in the Republican Party is willing to argue against his policy.
He is actually scaring people without work permits into leaving Florida for places like Indiana and North Carolina.
Whether Florida will actually be a better place after that is another story.
The Republican stand amounts to saying that all immigration is bad — and if you followed the logic you would apply that to births also.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/5/2023 @ 2:34 pmSome Republicans in Congress are very eager to blame the cocaine found (hidden) in the White House on Hunter Biden, even though he wasn’t there, and by all accounts, he finally kicked his drug addiction a few years ago. I don’t know why people want to act so stupid.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/5/2023 @ 2:37 pm235. whembly (5f7596) — 7/5/2023 @ 7:31 am
Its basically parts of northern Mexico, which is not controlled by the Mexican government.
https://www.utrgv.edu/human-trafficking/blog/northern-mexico/gulfcartel/index.htm
The United States could probably force the Mexican government to join in an operaton like it forced Pakistan in 2001.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/5/2023 @ 2:44 pmThat worked out really well-NOT!
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/5/2023 @ 3:01 pmWASHINGTON (AP) — Former President Donald Trump posted on his social media platform what he claimed was the home address of former President Barack Obama on the same day that a man with guns in his van was arrested near the property, federal prosecutors said Wednesday in revealing new details about the case.
Taylor Taranto, 37, who prosecutors say participated in the Jan. 6, 2021 riot at the U.S. Capitol, kept two firearms and hundreds of rounds of ammunition inside a van he had driven cross-country and had been living in, according to a Justice Department motion that seeks to keep him behind bars.
On the day of his June 29 arrest, prosecutors said, Taranto reposted a Truth Social post from Trump containing what Trump claimed was Obama’s home address. In a post on Telegram, Taranto wrote: “We got these losers surrounded! See you in hell, Podesta’s and Obama’s.” That’s a reference to John Podesta, the former chair of Hillary Clinton’s 2016 Democratic presidential campaign. GITMO, GITMO, po-pitmo
nk (90028a) — 7/5/2023 @ 4:42 pmBanana, fana, fo-fitmo
Fi, fie, mo-mitmo
Trump!
The supreme court in its never ending attempt to prevent republicans from ever getting elected to office again has angered The 80% of voters who oppose a ban on abortion. Not satisfied with that has angered blacks, native americans and latinx with affirmative action decision. Gays on discrimination and young voters over student loans. Who are they planning to enrage next to hate republicans?
asset (8c8f34) — 7/5/2023 @ 4:45 pmDamn them on student loans! It’s so unfair that people who took $200K loans for their art history majors are going to have to pay it back! Nobody warned hem!
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/5/2023 @ 4:53 pmEvery time the voters got a say on affirmative action, they voted it down. Every time.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/5/2023 @ 4:53 pmSammy,
Your open borders obsession is well known. Your desire to attack those who are trying to save America from invasion is disheartening to say the least.
Should Israel be forced to accept anyone who wants to go there?
NJRob (eb56c3) — 7/5/2023 @ 5:47 pmMajority of voters agree with the Supreme Court on the illegality of affirmative action, the duty to pay what you owe and the right to not be enslaved by someone with whom you disagree.
Asset keep on keeping on.
NJRob (eb56c3) — 7/5/2023 @ 5:50 pmAs a matter of pure principle, Harvard has the same right to pick and choose its students as the website designer has to pick and choose her clients. As a matter of Fourteenth Amendment law, too. It was the taking of government money that got it into trouble under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act.
The legacy lawsuit that has just been filed could be its watershed moment. Will the traditionalists inside Harvard prevail or will the wokes?
If Harvard eschews government money, it can have both its legacies and its affirmative actions as a matter of law. As a practical matter, it will not have all that many affirmative actions because not many will be able to afford it, but most legacies likely will.
Whichever, Harvard was and will remain the architect of its predicament.
nk (c97eec) — 7/5/2023 @ 7:08 pmConservatives: Term limits good! Get rid of pelosi, clyburn, hoyer, schumer, fienstein ect. Any of you here think they would be replaced by moderate corporate democrats or more squad members. Before AOC maybe after AOC NO! Clinton/Biden corporate wing of the party has been discredited. Their are budding AOC’s just waiting to take over like jessica cisneros in texas.
asset (8c8f34) — 7/5/2023 @ 7:39 pmArticle from 2030:
AOC, MTG, Boebert: Where are they now?
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/5/2023 @ 10:42 pm@278 mtg and boebert trailor park. AOC veep getting ready to run for president as minorities will be the majority. Ask any 13 year old latinx girl as they all want to be AOC! That was to easy of a softball.
asset (0ef808) — 7/5/2023 @ 11:23 pmLast I checked, 13 year olds don’t vote. Meanwhile the squad is chasing that girl’s parents into Trump’s arms.
You do realize that if and when AOC does take over your party, she’ll be the corporate Dem? In fact, according to the far left she already is.
lurker (cd7cd4) — 7/6/2023 @ 2:19 amAOC has bad economic ideas….which is sad since she has a degree in economics. Before she should consider a national run, AOC should demonstrate some executive competence…as a governor or at minimum as a cabinet secretary. The color of her skin, her heritage, or her gender tell us nothing about what type of leader she will be or the strength of her ideas. This is the opposite side of the Trump coin: liberal personality worship. If the message is utopian income and wealth redistribution, then we know all of that just shrinks the pie and discourages innovation, risk taking, and industriousness. It’s not about selling real solutions. It’s selling a fraud. We should know better.
AJ_Liberty (47a43e) — 7/6/2023 @ 7:35 amAOC es vendida.
Translation I’m going with in this case would be American equivalent politician heckle “sell out”
We will see if the left thinks she can move to national office when the teachers unions and their rank and file true believers start teaching their students about her all the time, making them read her book, by working her into every discussion etc.
steveg (b999ec) — 7/6/2023 @ 9:06 amTwo of the three could become speaker within the next two years.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/6/2023 @ 9:16 amOr vice president.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/6/2023 @ 9:18 amYou do realize that if and when AOC does take over your party, she’ll be the corporate Dem?
And the new Centrist Party will cheer.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/6/2023 @ 11:47 amAOC has bad economic ideas….which is sad since she has a degree in economics.
There are quite a few Marxist economics professors.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/6/2023 @ 11:47 amJim Miller (f2956e) — 7/5/2023 @ 9:11 am
They were. That was what caused an evacuation of the White House.
If they had been sure it was only illegal drugs, they just would have confiscated it, and logged it and turned it over to the FBI or whatever agency takes drugs confiscated on federal property, and we probably never would have heard about it.
Sammy Finkelman (1d53c7) — 7/6/2023 @ 12:26 pmThe White House lied about where the cocaine was located. I’m shocked. This is my shocked face.
NJRob (0259ed) — 7/6/2023 @ 12:35 pmSource
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/6/2023 @ 1:04 pmIt’s not a heavily trafficked area and more importantly, it’s not an area open to the public. But the media continues to run interference for the dictator in chief.
NJRob (0259ed) — 7/6/2023 @ 1:17 pm283, funny you should mention that….
https://www.thedailybeast.com/rep-marjorie-taylor-greene-booted-from-right-wing-house-freedom-caucus
All is proceeding swimmingly for Grand Old Dame President MTG 2040
urbanleftbehind (403093) — 7/6/2023 @ 2:00 pmAnd you know this how?
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/6/2023 @ 2:34 pmThey did say something about people who go there needing to pass a vetting, which doesn’t make sense for ordinary tourists. They also said something about how it could be people given a privately guided tour by White House staff.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/6/2023 @ 3:21 pmThey don’t really want to know, because they don’t know what feathers they will ruffle.
nk (aa44a6) — 7/6/2023 @ 3:30 pmIn Mexico the cartels have a byword: silver or lead. They not only bribe people they kill. U.S. troops would tend to be immune from the latter (targeted assassinations) Bribery can be avoided by careful supervision.]
El Salvador got rid of a lot of the gang terror by suspending civil liberties and mass arrests, sometimes of the wrong people.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/may/16/how-two-colombians-were-ensnared-in-bukeles-gang-crackdown-in-el-salvador#:~:text=The%20Salvadorian%20government%20says%20it,caught%20up%20in%20the%20offensive.
This is also a campaign issue in Guatemala.
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/25/world/americas/guatemala-presidential-election.html
Torres is for mass arrests. Arévalo was not expected to do so well, but gained after other candidates were knocked out.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/6/2023 @ 3:41 pmIt could be any one of say 1,000 people who brought cocaine into the White House and decided to abandon it (or retrieve it on the way out?)
The Secret Service dogs, I read, sniff for explosives, not drugs.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/6/2023 @ 3:44 pmComer is from Kentucky and basically in he same political lane as Mitch McConnell.
What he said on Newsmax doesn’t make too much sense.
So they have six decisions affecting China, (out of dozens) four made after Biden was president, that they cannot figure out make any sense.
You could allege bribery maybe, except there’s no money, or appeasement, or bribery of appointees, but blackmail??
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/6/2023 @ 3:50 pmMeta (Facebook) has stated up a competition to Twitter called Threads. Musk is arguing it copies it too much or something.
Musk limited the number of Twitter messages that could be read by one account because he wants to prevent scraping (and in the process apparently cut off access to anyone who is not logged in)
He particularly links it with Artificial Intelligence which he does not like
You don’t need to be logged in to see this:
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1674942336583757825
What MMusk did particularly harmed meterologists.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/6/2023 @ 3:58 pmLOL! Comer is MAGA.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/6/2023 @ 4:00 pmShocking!
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/6/2023 @ 4:00 pmOr wishful thinking.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/6/2023 @ 4:01 pmIn polls, more people think Biden should not run than think Trump should not, but Trump has an overall greater unfavorable rating.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/6/2023 @ 4:06 pm, Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/6/2023 @ 4:01 pm
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/6/2023 @ 4:01 pm
It;s the same stupid idea that was said about Trump.
A corrupter is not going to blackmail someone about the corruption they caused.
Comer is going along with members of his committee.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/6/2023 @ 4:10 pmThe concept is bad. It originates I think with the FBI.
Sammy Finkelman (1d215a) — 7/6/2023 @ 4:11 pmComer is the leader of the Republican members of his committee.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/6/2023 @ 4:30 pmWatching Clear and Present Danger too many times:
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/6/2023 @ 4:40 pmBecause it’s not open to the public. I do appreciate you being the stenographer for Karine Jean Pierre. Not as much as she appreciates it I’m sure.
NJRob (c2fb50) — 7/6/2023 @ 5:02 pmPeggy Noonan on the GOP candidates:
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/6/2023 @ 5:18 pmdeploying the U.S. military on domestic soil to perform law-enforcement functions is illegal
Maybe. And maybe it’s 6-3 not.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/6/2023 @ 5:20 pmChristie couldn’t defeat a ham sandwich.
NJRob (c2fb50) — 7/6/2023 @ 5:29 pmIf you have a quote to the contrary, please post and link to it. Otherwise you’re just pulling it out of somewhere.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/6/2023 @ 5:34 pmMore constitutional fantasy camp.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/6/2023 @ 5:43 pmRIP producer Lawrence Turman (96). Produced The Graduate, The Great White Hope, The Thing, American History X, The Drowning Pool, Big Night, and The Mean Season.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/6/2023 @ 5:57 pmHey, Rip, I don’t advocate it either, but there is no telling what the Supreme Court may do when you scream “invasion” and “national emergency.” The Constitution does give the Executive rather awesome emergency powers, espcially when a state governor is asking for help.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/6/2023 @ 6:57 pmPosse (No, Donald!) Comitatus has a lot of exceptions. Delta Force was used for drug interdiction before Chuck Norris became a Texas Ranger. Eisenhower used federal troops to desegregate Little Rock. The only absolute ban, for now, is the deployment of nuclear submarines.
nk (a4bb80) — 7/6/2023 @ 7:02 pmKevin Williamson takes rather a good swipe at AOC:
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/6/2023 @ 7:03 pmEisenhower used federal troops to desegregate Little Rock.
The the point of fixing bayonets and walking the crowd back.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/6/2023 @ 7:05 pmU.S. troops would tend to be immune from the latter (targeted assassinations) Bribery can be avoided by careful supervision.
It would be as much fun as the British operation in Belfast.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/6/2023 @ 7:07 pmThanks for clarifying, I was afraid you were advocating governing by 6-3 (or 5-4) votes.
Rip Murdock (5479b6) — 7/6/2023 @ 7:08 pmNo, I’m stating a fact. It’s a non-public area. That’s not high traffic by definition. Everyone has to be cleared to be there. Your parroting the administration’s lies is you pushing propaganda.
NJRob (eb56c3) — 7/6/2023 @ 8:39 pmhttps://boundingintocomics.com/2023/06/07/the-walt-disney-company-reportedly-shelved-anti-child-trafficking-film-sound-of-freedom-after-obtaining-rights-in-merger-with-fox/
NJRob (eb56c3) — 7/6/2023 @ 8:48 pmChristie couldn’t defeat a ham sandwich.
He destroyed Rubio’s entire campaign in 2 minutes.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/6/2023 @ 11:26 pm@280 we were discussing 2030 when the 13 year old latinx girl will be 20. Only half of generation z is of voting age and they vote the heaviest democrat. By the way supposedly their is a picture of the bag the cocaine was found in white house with the inscription “property of H. biden.” AOC corporate democrat? Tell that to to former congressman sean patrick maloney. The far left are purists I know I am one! Some out here in left field call bernie a sell out. Means nothing. 100,000 minorities turn voting age every month and nearly half that many republicans die each month Means something. 65/70% latinx vote democrat and nearly half of those who don’t are cuban americans.
asset (5a7e88) — 7/7/2023 @ 12:06 amKevin,
Destroying doesn’t mean he wins. He couldn’t beat Rubio head to head or anyone else that is nominally a republican. Maybe Hutchinson, but that’s not a viable option in any reality that exists.
It’s just tilting at windmills.
NJRob (eb56c3) — 7/7/2023 @ 5:49 amEisenhower used troops to enforce a federal court order (which the State of Arkansas was willfully blocking), not for ordinary law enforcement purposes.
Rip Murdock (d2a2a8) — 7/7/2023 @ 9:12 amKevin M (2d6744) — 7/6/2023 @ 6:57 pm
It doesn’t, although a law may delegate more power to the president than otherwise under certain circumstances.
The only place unenumerated emergency powers may exist is with the states, as we saw during Covid, and that’s authorized and limited by state laws and the state constitution.
Sammy Finkelman (896511) — 7/7/2023 @ 10:18 amEisenhower used troops to enforce a federal court order (which the State of Arkansas was willfully blocking), not for ordinary law enforcement purposes.
Now do sanctuary states.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/7/2023 @ 11:11 amThe Constitution does give the Executive rather awesome emergency powers, especially when a state governor is asking for help.
The Constitution makes the President Commander-in-Chief. While Congress has attempted several times to restrict that power, no President has agreed.
The Guarantee Clause states:
This allows the President to use troops unilaterally in cases of invasion, and with a request, in cases of civil disorder. There are additional situations where Congress has authorized the use of troops domestically irrespective of Posse Comitatus. The Insurrection Act and the Enforcement Acts are two examples.
W attempted to amend the Insurrection Act after Katrina, to allow US troops to restore order after a natural disaster, despite the state’s governor objection. The amendment passed but was repealed a year later.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/7/2023 @ 11:35 amDestroying doesn’t mean he wins.
You are right, but I would like to see him destroy Trump on stage. Assuming that his cult would listen.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/7/2023 @ 11:37 am“Now do sanctuary states.”
State police are not obligated to enforce federal laws.
Davethulhu (8a303d) — 7/7/2023 @ 5:39 pmRe Marge being voted out of the HFC, I’m reading that Rep. Andy Harris said of the vote:
What the heck? Is he saying that if it had been members who were male nothing would’ve happened because men? Unbelievable.
Dana (560c99) — 7/7/2023 @ 5:45 pmWhat the heck? Is he saying that if it had been members who were male nothing would’ve happened because men? Unbelievable.
Sugar and spice and everything nice.
Toads and snails and puppy dog tails.
This the Freedom Caucus, remember? They’re supposed to have those quaint, old-fashioned notions. That’s what they run on, that’s what gets them elected.
And I also think that MTG is rude, crude, and tawdry, I could even say cheap, and not a lady you bring home to meet your parents, and I’m not even in the Freedom Caucus.
nk (8d3cf1) — 7/7/2023 @ 5:57 pmState police are not obligated to enforce federal laws.
No, but federal police can. And state police who are actively working to thwart federal laws can be prosecuted for obstruction.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/7/2023 @ 6:13 pmEisenhower used troops to enforce a federal court order (which the State of Arkansas was willfully blocking), not for ordinary law enforcement purposes.
Ike actually used the Enforcement Acts, passed in 1870-1, which allowed the use of troops to stop racial violence. They had been moribund for a number of years due to post-Reconstruction Supreme Court rulings that limited the 14th and 15th Amendments. But as those rules were overturned these limitations were removed, so long as state actors were involved.
There is no doubt, however, that immigration laws can be enforced anywhere by the federal government (it is an enumerated power), and that troops can be used in some circumstances. Posse Comitatus is not as broad as some think.
Kevin M (2d6744) — 7/7/2023 @ 6:27 pm