Patterico's Pontifications

9/5/2009

The Transparent One Takes One Small Step

Filed under: Obama — DRJ @ 3:28 pm



[Guest post by DRJ]

The LA Times reports President Barack Obama is keeping his promise to run the most transparent Administration in history:

“In a statement issued Friday from Camp David, Md., Obama said his administration would post information online each month detailing White House visitors during the prior three or four months.

“For the first time in history, records of White House visitors will be made available to the public on an ongoing basis,” Obama said, adding that he would make his “the most open and transparent administration in history, not only by opening the doors of the White House to more Americans, but by shining a light on the business conducted inside.

“Americans have a right to know whose voices are being heard in the policymaking process.”

The decision was made after a federal judge ruled in favor of Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics (CREW), a group that sued the Bush Administration claiming White House records of visits by conservative Christian leaders should be subject to FOIA requests. The group renewed its claim after Obama took office but “Obama’s staff originally refused to give up the records.” CREW threatened to sue the Obama Administration in July 2009 and a CREW blog post described the Obama Administration’s refusal to release health care policy visitor logs as a continuation of “one of the bad, anti-transparency, pro-secrecy approaches” of the Bush administration.

I have a feeling the court’s decision and CREW’s agreement to settle its lawsuits had more to do with the Obama Administration’s decision than a desire for transparency. Interestingly, the Obama Administration also agreed to turn over records of Bush era visitors and I expect to see more media interest in those logs than in Obama’s:

“The government initially refused to turn over these records, but now has agreed to produce them, as well as the Bush era records, as part of the settlement.”

There are exceptions to what the Obama Administration says it will release from its records, including visits by potential Supreme Court nominees, covert operatives (“White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs [said the] point of the exception is to ‘protect those whose lives you could endanger’ by revealing them”), personal visits to the Obama daughters, possibly visits on Air Force One and at Camp David, and any other information the White House decides not to release. However, “the White House will report the number of meetings it is holding back and release the visitors’ names ‘when it is more appropriate to do so.'”

Meanwhile, CREW is willing to forget the Obama Administration’s continued resistance to releasing visitor records and forgive its plan to selectively withhold future records. Instead CREW is pleased, apparently in part because the Obama Administration is good and the Bush Administration is bad:

“CREW Executive Director Melanie Sloan praised the White House, stating, ‘The Obama administration has proven its pledge to usher in a new era of government transparency was more than just a campaign promise. The Bush administration fought tooth and nail to keep secret the identities of those who visited the White House. In contrast, the Obama administration – by putting visitor records on the White House web site – will have the most open White House in history. Because visitor records will now be available online, CREW dismissed its lawsuits.’ Sloan continued, ‘Providing public access to visitor records is an important step in restoring transparency and accountability to our government. CREW is proud to have been part of this historic decision.’”

See how easy it is to deliver transparency in government? All it takes is one small step …

— DRJ

14 Responses to “The Transparent One Takes One Small Step”

  1. “Transparent” is correct, as in “obvious”, “self-serving”, “pandering”; you name it.

    Icy Texan (817dff)

  2. You don’t drop in enough, Icy. I hope everything is going well for you.

    DRJ (3f5471)

  3. #1 IT~ What DRJ said.

    EW1(SG) (edc268)

  4. “… CREW is pleased…”
    Once again, the immature and logic challenged, are distracted by something shiney glittering in the distance;
    Oh, and by the usual bunnies and unicorns too!

    AD - RtR/OS! (552fc3)

  5. “…and any other information the White House decides not to release.”

    So the Bush administration essentially says “we’re not going to tell you anything. Piss off”. And they’re baaaaad.

    The Obama administration says “we’re only going to tell you what we want, when we want” And they’re the most transparent administration evah.

    Well…did we really expect anything different?

    KB (f2b2b3)

  6. Looks like the Obama kids will be getting to meet a lot of movers and shakers and lobbyists.

    Gazzer (1bc622)

  7. On the broader question, who agrees that WH visitor logs should be secret?

    Deepthought (54d9f4)

  8. “See how easy it is to deliver transparency in government? All it takes is one small step …”

    I heard they were also undoing the Ashcroft memo to the departments. That held up a lot of FOIA work outside of this white house political stuff.

    imdw (034b9e)

  9. Well heck, as long as their transparent in an opaquely kind of way, it’s all good.

    Ag80 (b272f0)

  10. And, of course I meant “they’re” not “their.”

    Ag80 (b272f0)

  11. Either the logs should entirely be public, or entirely secret. There’s no purpose to making them half-public.

    steve miller (c5e78c)

  12. Either the logs should entirely be public, or entirely secret. There’s no purpose to making them half-public.
    OH! You’re my new favorite blogger fyi

    steve miller (3fb4a8)

  13. “Either the logs should entirely be public, or entirely secret. There’s no purpose to making them half-public.”

    Just about all open government laws have exceptions, and when documents are released, things that belong to the exceptions are blacked out.

    imdw (f46f2b)

  14. Hey, friends! Just livin’ out here around the childhood home of George W & Laura (somewhere near DRJ, I believe), working my butt off. Don’t have as much time to hang out here as I used to.

    Icy Texan (43c637)


Powered by WordPress.

Page loaded in: 0.0815 secs.