Patterico's Pontifications

10/15/2005

Krugman on Misleading Readers Without a Formal Correction

Filed under: Media Bias,Scum — Patterico @ 1:25 pm



Paul Krugman:

More broadly, the big problem with political reporting based on character portraits is that there are no rules, no way for a reporter to be proved wrong. If a reporter tells you about the steely resolve of a politician who turns out to be ineffectual and unwilling to make hard choices, you’ve been misled, but not in a way that requires a formal correction.

Similarly, if a columnist like myself tells you that “a full manual recount would have given the election to Mr. Gore,” and that assertion turns out to be unsupported by the evidence, and no correct correction is ever appended to the article making that assertion, then you’ve been misled — but I’ll fight a formal correction tooth and nail.

Whoops! Only the first paragraph is Krugman. I made up the second one. It’s how Krugman feels, but he hasn’t said so in so many words.

By the by, his August 19 and August 22 columns contain incorrect corrections (as described in this post) that still remain uncorrected to this very day. It’s clear by now that they will never be corrected. Ever.

Hence the filing of this post in the “Scum” category.

(Thanks to Shredstar for the pointer.)

2 Responses to “Krugman on Misleading Readers Without a Formal Correction”

  1. Well just how delusional, just how tenuous is Krugman’s grip on reality?

    Consider these words he penned awhile back (8.19.05): In his recent book “Steal This Vote” – a very judicious work, despite its title – Andrew Gumbel, a U.S. correspondent for the British newspaper The Independent, provides the best overview I’ve seen of the 2000 Florida vote. And he documents the simple truth: “Al Gore won the 2000 presidential election.”

    When caught pushing this lie, the clueless Krugman issued this supposed retraction

    Even the New York Swine Time with Slime had a different take: EXAMINING THE VOTE: THE OVERVIEW; Study of Disputed Florida Ballots Finds Justices Did Not Cast the Deciding Vote

    Thankfully we have folks like Don Luskin chronicling the inanities of fools like Krugman along with giving us the factual news on items like the economy…

    russ (8b209b)

  2. Delusion

    Patterco pontificates on Paul Krugman’s inability to be corrected.

    Stupid Random Thoughts (08b9ad)


Powered by WordPress.

Page loaded in: 0.0689 secs.