Patterico's Pontifications

8/10/2015

Because Nothing Says ‘Protecting Her Honor’ Like A Father Letting His Own Daughter Drown

Filed under: General — Dana @ 11:22 pm



[guest post by Dana]

A despicable bastard fought to let his daughter drown rather than have strange men make physical contact with her to save her life:

Speaking to Emirates 24|7, Lt. Col Ahmed Burqibah, Deputy Director of Dubai Police’s Search and Rescue Department said that this incident took place at a beach in Dubai.

“This is one of the incidents which I cannot forget.

“It shocked me and many others who were involved in the case.

“The *Asian father took his wife and kids to the beach for picnic and fun.

“The kids were swimming in the beach when suddenly, the 20-year-old girl started drowning and screaming for help.

“Two rescue men were at the beach, and they rushed to help the girl.

“However, there was one obstacle which prevented them from reaching the girl and helping her.

“This obstacle was the belief of this Asian man who considered that if these men touched his daughter, then this would dishonour her. It cost him the life of his daughter.”

Lt. Col. Burqibah added that the father of the girl did not want the rescue men to touch his daughter as they were strange men.

“The father was a tall and strong man. He started pulling and preventing the rescue men and got violent with them. He told them that he prefers his daughter being dead than being touched by a strange man.”

He pointed out that this delay and fight with the girl’s father cost the girl her life. She drowned.

“She died unfortunately, at a time when she had a chance to live, especially that the rescue men were so close to her to pull her out of the water.”

So horrible, and so pointless. A young woman, struggling to remain afloat and stay alive, sees her strong and fit father condemn her to certain death as he prevents her would-be rescuers from reaching her. In the name of honor. In the name of madness.

If that wasn’t enough, he made sure she knew, in her last moments of life, just how irrelevant she was as he remained safely on shore without any surging power of parental love compelling him to risk his own life in an effort to save hers. The man she knew as father did not crash through the surf and push with all his might against the waves in a Herculean effort to reach her in time. She was alone.

If this madness is what protecting the honor of one’s own flesh and blood supposedly looks like, what a ghastly lie with which to deceive oneself. And what an ever more ghastly thing with which to condemn others. It is not born of love, but rather it comes from the vilest roots of a deadened heart. There is no mercy, no compassion, no kindness, just darkness. And in its hold is not even the most basic response of human nature, wherein a man is compelled to at least try and rescue those in danger, because in that very moment he recognizes that life itself demands it.

[link added –Ed.]

–Dana

175 Responses to “Because Nothing Says ‘Protecting Her Honor’ Like A Father Letting His Own Daughter Drown”

  1. Hello.

    Dana (86e864)

  2. Asian, huh? So I guess those damn Buddhists are sentencing their daughters to death rather than let them be touched by nonbelievers. Not too Zen of them, I daresay.

    JVW (ba78f9)

  3. Was the man (and i use the term loosely) arrested?

    seeRpea (348a52)

  4. Barbaric bastard.

    mg (31009b)

  5. In a sane world, this “father” would be shot. For over one billion muslims, he is “understood”. Welcome to the 9th Century.

    Roman (24c8f9)

  6. What a loathsome animal and embarrassment to the human race. This must be the kind of whack job that the most radical feminists think most men are.

    If there’s any justice in this world, he’ll be punished for this. Personally, I propose that he be sentenced to parachuting out of an airplane into the middle of the ocean. And if by some chance he makes it back to the mainland, repeat the process.

    tops116 (d094f8)

  7. Why wouldn’t the father himself have tried to rescue his daughter? Him touching her would not have violated any honor codes, and any actual man would have been so caught up in trying to rescue his daughter that he wouldn’t have had time to think about any honor violations if another man helped.

    For some reason, this male — he wasn’t a man — wanted his daughter dead.

    The Dana who wonders if there is more to the story (f6a568)

  8. Inconceivable.

    JD (1dfdde)

  9. If a general nuclear war kicked off between Israel and middle eastern Islamic nations, I’d mourn for every Jewish life lost. That is all.

    Mr Black (f1b3a7)

  10. He’s been arrested. They can be very interesting in the Dubai courts.. this is more common unfortunately, many of the rescue services are. Non Muslim expatriates, stories of life saving medical attention being withheld are not reported as much either, with the growing. ChristIna and Jewish population, the Arabs are having to come to the realization that their dominance is waning

    Epwj (4df1f9)

  11. oh no no no it was too cold always
    (still the dead girl lay moaning)
    I was much too far out all my life

    and not waving but drowning

    happyfeet (5546fb)

  12. Many of our current difficulties are directly a result of taking an insane, barbaric death cult and treating it as if it were a religion.

    Estragon (ada867)

  13. The father should now be beheaded for bringing infamy on Islam. It was all his fault for allowing his daughter to bathe in a public place in the presence and in the gaze of strange men, in the first place.

    nk (dbc370)

  14. In 2002, a school in Makkah, Saudi Arabia burned down. This was a girls’ school. Fifteen girls lost their lives, not due to lack of firefighting competence or personnel, but because the muttawa (religious police) interfered, refusing to let the firefighters enter or the girls to leave because the girls were ‘uncovered’.

    There is something inherently damaged about these people, damaged in ways that would make a sub-Saharan African tribesman — the kind who is still impressed by lightbulbs — say ‘You know, you’re not civilized worth a shit!’

    Toastrider (4c0340)

  15. I read that the father was arrested and charged – for attacking the lifeguards.

    Further, consider that it is very likely the daughter was not wearing a bathing suit, but instead was wearing a chador or her clothes, both of which would weigh her down. Certainly she was not wearing a typical bathing suit.

    Dana (86e864)

  16. How many guys does it take to get Dad tangled up so he can’t do anything about other guys trying to save the woman? One. Those lifeguards were too damn’ nice.

    Richard Aubrey (f6d8de)

  17. my guess is her life was a big pile of suck anyways with an arranged marriage to look forward to plus twice-weekly beatings, sexual degradation, limited employment opportunities and little or no time for pets or hobbies

    happyfeet (a037ad)

  18. Here, distilled to its essence, are the ethics of Islam on full display.

    David Longfellow (8cba7a)

  19. Sorry, Mr. Longfellow, but you mean the essence of Asian ethics. No where in this article is the word islam mentioned.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  20. Yeah, this would not have happened in Albania, Bosnia, Northern Cyprus, or even most of Turkey. It was a camel-molesting Pakistani, that’s who the Brits call “Asian”.

    nk (dbc370)

  21. I prefer the Japanese view. You don’t willingly live under same skyy as your father died under.

    A samurai killed Shinobu’s father. Shinobu and her sister
    challenged him to a duel. They found a ronin to teach them.

    Legend has it, as legend’s always do.

    But not without truth.

    The naginata is known as the woman’s spear for a reason.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  22. But soon it could happen in: Detroit, DC, Cedar Rapids, Philly, NYC, Atlanta, Peoria, Frisco, Houston and Chicago. These are the top ten US cities in moslem population. Looks like mohammad is coming to the mountain after all. Lucky us.

    BTW, why on earth Peoria?

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  23. The Japanese woman’s knife is the kaiken. It was
    basically equivalent to the man’s side sword, the wakizashi.

    An internet search didn’t turn up much on Shinobu. Sorry.
    She should be remembered.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  24. Pre-occupation, Japanese women would have considered Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan, and Pakistan hotbeds of radical feminism. Japanese women were chattels to be sold, mortgaged, and attached for the payment of debts, of their senior male relative, or the male relative’s superior. Among other things.

    nk (dbc370)

  25. The Imam Barack Hussein Hoagie asked:

    BTW, why on earth Peoria?

    They wanted to work at Caterpillar.

    The economist Dana (f6a568)

  26. The kwaiken is a tanto variant, similar to the aiguchi, a tanto without a guard.

    nk (dbc370)

  27. What “pre-occupation” are you referring to, nk?

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  28. Pre our occupation from 1945 to 1952, Hoagie. We brought civilization to Japan.

    nk (dbc370)

  29. We brought Westernization to Japan. They were already civilized.

    BTW, my wife arrived from Beijing to Seoul Sunday. I’m being hit with pictures all over the place. Thank God for Kakao the texts, pix and calls are free.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  30. Steve, maybe it was a nom de guerre?

    Shinobu (しのぶ?) is a Japanese verb meaning “recall” (偲ぶ?) or “stealth/endure” (忍ぶ?). It is a Japanese given name used by either sex. Shinobu is also the dictionary form of shinobi which can be combined with mono (者) to make shinobi no mono (忍びの者), an alternative name of ninja.

    (From Wikipedia)

    kishnevi (294553)

  31. It was all his fault for allowing his daughter to bathe in a public place in the presence and in the gaze of strange men, in the first place.

    There is a story from the Iranian revolution period about two daughters of a family who lived in a walled compound. The daughters were swimming in western style bathing suits. Several revolutionary types were on the roof of a high rise in Tehran with a telescope and watched the girls swimming, then went down and arrested them for indecency. I believe they were executed.

    Mike K (90dfdc)

  32. I used Skype while the daughter was in Greece but I uninstalled it now that she’s back because it was driving svchost crazy even when it was not running, eating up half the CPU capacity and 300 megs of memory on Windows 7 64-bit. Does anybody else have the same problems with it?

    nk (dbc370)

  33. I was going for Skype but one of the Korean kids put Kakao on so I use that. Seems good.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  34. Look, some Cultures are simply much better than others. There is a reason these Countries never advanced …. same token, Culture is the reason our Country is regressing.

    Rodney King's Spirit (9225a4)

  35. They call them SW Asians in the Great Britain news whenever there is some form of Muslim outrage event in the UK. which is code for Pakistani.
    I’m gonna go out on a limb and say the Muslim immigration experiment is a failure.

    Dubai needs more lifeguards like the one from Venice Pier who knocked an idiot out.

    http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-lifeguard-attack-venice-20150731-story.html

    steveg (fed1c9)

  36. I’m gonna go out on a limb and say the Muslim immigration experiment is a failure.

    Au contraire, steveg. It’s doing exactly what the moslems planned it to do.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  37. Yeah, this would not have happened in Albania, Bosnia, Northern Cyprus, or even most of Turkey. It was a camel-molesting Pakistani, that’s who the Brits call “Asian”.

    After my outrage subsided by inner nastiness took over and my next thought was that there is some first cousin in Pakistan who just lost his future bride.

    JVW (ba78f9)

  38. Culture is the reason our Country is regressing.

    Seems to me Rodney, we are regressing away from culture, our culture. See, under PC rules and regulations all cultures are equally good and none should be given preferential treatment. So our culture which designed a system where the power lies with the people rather than a king, that used capitalism to raise the standards for the poor and rich, that used industry and technology to better billions of lives is no better than those tribes who “click” at each other or moslems who watch their daughters drown.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  39. hy wouldn’t the father himself have tried to rescue his daughter? Him touching her would not have violated any honor codes, and any actual man would have been so caught up in trying to rescue his daughter that he wouldn’t have had time to think about any honor violations if another man helped.

    You may be on to something, Dana, but my guess is that the guy didn’t know how to swim. It also sounds like the lifeguards were curiously passive. I can get having to deal with a guy bigger than you are, but the guy would have have been able to fend off two or three lifeguards rushing into the ocean. At best he might have stopped one or possibly two. I’m an ex-lifeguard, and it boggles the mind that you would just stand there and allow yourself to be prevented from reaching the victim.

    JVW (ba78f9)

  40. JVW wrote:

    It also sounds like the lifeguards were curiously passive. I can get having to deal with a guy bigger than you are, but the guy would have have been able to fend off two or three lifeguards rushing into the ocean. At best he might have stopped one or possibly two.

    All that the lifeguards had to do was get fifteen feet apart from each other, and the “father” could not have intercepted them both, but it sounds like they didn’t think of it.

    The Dana who's been in a fight or two . . . not that he always won (f6a568)

  41. The Lifeguards should be terminated and charged with manslaughter.

    Two idiots sitting around respecting some morons wishes while a kid drowns is criminal.

    Rodney King's Spirit (9225a4)

  42. The burquini, courtesy of Big Lizards.

    nk (dbc370)

  43. wow, big lizards , talk about a blast from the past.
    this is still a classic , http://biglizards.net/Graphics/ForegroundPix/Forward.jpg though we are past that point and in the drain.

    this OP story does show how two extreme points of religion can come to the same disregard for humanity. PlannedParenthood and ultra-Muslim types in recent news.

    seeRpea (348a52)

  44. Apparently this is the new TruSpeak. Calling Muslim men ASIANS because somehow
    mideastern refugees or immigrants are ASIAN.

    Can the media ever be so transparent? Especially when they think they’re hiding
    what they’re true agenda is?

    Somehow they think that our anger and fear towards mideaster men will go away
    if they label them ASIANS?

    If I was Chinese or Japanese or any other genuine oriental race or ethnicity,
    I’d sue.

    jakee308 (c37f85)

  45. I’m amused, jakee308. My wife is South Korean and I thought she was an Asian. I lovingly call her my “ornamental”. I guess since she’s Buddhist she doesn’t count. Right now she’s in Seoul, just in from Beijing. Supposed to be home Sunday. Korean Air flight 85 to JFK. Can’t wait.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  46. nk, you find stuff I never knew existed. Wow! Big Lizards indeed. I love it.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  47. Dafydd used to be a regular commenter, here. He was also married to an “ornamental” lady the last I read.

    nk (dbc370)

  48. I finally understand something I heard as a child. “Some people, they just need killing.” In this case, shackle his feet to a ton weight so his armpits are above the water at low tide and wait. Retrieve the skeleton after a year, incinerate it, and scatter the ashes in an unknown place.

    htom (4ca1fa)

  49. At the risk of sounding jaded…. Moslems have been at war with us for how long? They’re always burning flags and yelling “Death to America”. They’re perpetually outraged at everything Western. So this clown kills his daughter. That’s one less moslem. We win. She was a breeder and may have had a litter of little moslemettes. Another win for us. We should be paying these guys. If it’s okay for the feds to pay Planned Parenthood to kill little black babies like Sanger wanted why not pay for these guys to whack each other?

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  50. Why yes, that does sound a tad jaded.

    Leviticus (f9a067)

  51. The leftists embrace the culture and condemn rightwing for the lack of tolerance of other cultures.

    Not paying for free birth control is the real war on women

    Joe (debac0)

  52. About 50 times more Americans have been killed by Buddhists than by Muslims.
    That many again by Lutherans.
    All within living memory.
    We can quibble that some of the Buddhists were Shintoists or atheist Communists, and that some of the Lutherans were Catholics or some other kind of Protestants, and what difference would it make?

    nk (dbc370)

  53. category error, NK, they killed because they were Buddhists or some other motivator, and Shinto is like a whole other religion, if memory serves,

    narciso (ee1f88)

  54. It was an after birth abortion in the 81st trimester.

    papertiger (c2d6da)

  55. Somethings wrong with that math.

    papertiger (c2d6da)

  56. We can quibble that some of the Buddhists were Shintoists or atheist Communists, and that some of the Lutherans were Catholics or some other kind of Protestants, and what difference would it make?

    It makes all the difference in the world. You just can’t start plugging in new names to suit your argument unless you’re a leftist plugging in Asian for moslem or secular for heathen or Caitlyn for Bruce. Then it’s okay.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  57. kishnevi @29, I never knew that. Thanks.

    I wish I could find the details of the story of the tale of Shinobu. As I recall a samurai had killed her father. And as a commoner the samurai had the right to kill him.

    I realize now I’m not clear as to whether it was a sister or a brother that helped her get her revenge.

    I am amused by nk’s characterization of Japanese women.

    …It is a Japanese given name used by either sex…

    As an aside, and far be it from me to dispute what you’ll find in Wikipedia, but the only Japanese I ever met named Shinobu were women.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  58. 40. JVW wrote:

    It also sounds like the lifeguards were curiously passive. I can get having to deal with a guy bigger than you are, but the guy would have have been able to fend off two or three lifeguards rushing into the ocean. At best he might have stopped one or possibly two.

    All that the lifeguards had to do was get fifteen feet apart from each other, and the “father” could not have intercepted them both, but it sounds like they didn’t think of it.

    The Dana who’s been in a fight or two . . . not that he always won (f6a568) — 8/11/2015 @ 8:49 am

    The lifeguards may have just been dispirited by the sheer pointlessness of rescuing the daughter. They could have overwhelmed dad and pulled the young lady out. But to what end? She’d have ended up killed as damaged goods a few hours later.

    JVW also wrote this about dear old dad:

    …You may be on to something, Dana, but my guess is that the guy didn’t know how to swim…

    A bit of free advice, which is worth what you pay for it. If you’re ever in a position to rescue a drowning man, or woman who can be holy terrors as well, and they put up a fight, dive. And drowning people will fight you. They’re operating on their lizard brains. They are not going to appreciate your presence as anything more than something to climb onto and get out of the water.

    They won’t follow you down.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  59. Pre-occupation, Japanese women would have considered Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan, and Pakistan hotbeds of radical feminism. Japanese women were chattels to be sold, mortgaged, and attached for the payment of debts, of their senior male relative, or the male relative’s superior. Among other things.

    Chattels are valued. She wasn’t.

    NickM (63e1a7)

  60. …So horrible, and so pointless. A young woman, struggling to remain afloat and stay alive, sees her strong and fit father condemn her to certain death as he prevents her would-be rescuers from reaching her. In the name of honor. In the name of madness.

    If that wasn’t enough, he made sure she knew, in her last moments of life, just how irrelevant she was as he remained safely on shore without any surging power of parental love compelling him to risk his own life in an effort to save hers. The man she knew as father did not crash through the surf and push with all his might against the waves in a Herculean effort to reach her in time. She was alone…

    I’m not making excuses for this guy. I am just passing along what I observed.

    I’ve known let’s say a few middle eastern families, Muslims and Christians. And it wasn’t the dad who was the primary problem. It was Mom. For instance, there was this Egyptian Copt girl I knew at the community college. One morning she got into a very bad car accident. Her car was rear ended by one semi, and crashed into the semi ahead of her. She should have gone to the hospital but instead she came to school. She was in agony, but she didn’t know what else to do.

    Upshot was we got ahold of her dad at his office, and he couldn’t have been nicer. He was just so grateful we had seen to his daughter, and he came and got her and took her to get medical attention.

    She was afraid of her mom. It was mom who made her life h3ll and enforced the moral code. And I can kind of understand why, if you understand I’m using the term understand how I’m using it. I do not approve. I can simply see how it can make sense.

    If you are so inclined, google the terms copt, egypt, and rape.

    Mom didn’t want that for her daughter. The sheer paranoia led to a firm conviction that if she let go of the iron grip over her daughter, sinister things would happen.

    Like I said I’m not making excuses. But these are my observations, for what they’re worth. Fear. They’re marinated in it. What would other people think?

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  61. Steve57, From Wikipedia:

    Wakanosato Shinobu (born July 10, 1976 as Shinobu Kogawa) is a professional sumo wrestler from Hirosaki, Aomori, Japan. He made his debut in the top division in 1998, and his highest rank has been sekiwake. He holds the record for the most consecutive tournaments ranked in the junior san’yaku ranks of sekiwake and komusubi (19 from 2002 until 2005). He has won ten special prizes and has twice been runner-up in a tournament. He is also tied for fourth on the list of gold star earning active wrestlers by defeating yokozuna as an untitled wrestler.

    ropelight (8383a5)

  62. About 50 times more Americans have been killed by Buddhists than by Muslims.
    That many again by Lutherans.
    All within living memory.
    We can quibble that some of the Buddhists were Shintoists or atheist Communists, and that some of the Lutherans were Catholics or some other kind of Protestants, and what difference would it make?

    nk (dbc370) — 8/11/2015 @ 11:49 am

    I don’t think I’ve seen a more intellectually dishonest statement.
    There is no Buddhist Nation or movement calling for Death to America.
    There is no Lutheran or Christian Nation or movement calling for Death to America.
    There are multiple Islamic nations and movements calling for Death to America.

    Moreover your snark implying murderous justification from the religion practiced in the Axis nations has nothing to do with the reason for the killing. Neither Luther nor Buddha required world domination.

    Your slip is showing NK

    Steve Malynn (6b1ce5)

  63. “Asian” in this context means Indian, Pakistani, Sri Lanka. It’s not PC, it’s just British. Asia is a big place. In America Asian means “East Asian” and in the UK Asian means “South Asian”.

    The 7/7 bombings in London caused confusion with American bloggers because the suspects were described as being “black or Asian”; they didn’t see how the two could possibly be confused.

    Gabriel Hanna (64d4e1)

  64. 63.“Asian” in this context means Indian, Pakistani, Sri Lanka. It’s not PC, it’s just British.

    I know what it means Mr. Hanna. As an American I was being snarky.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  65. ropelight, thanks for the info. I had never met a Japanese man named Shinobu, and I thought it was a woman’s name. Then kishnevi and you filled me in.

    It wasn’t my personal experience, but then I’ve driven across Wyoming and never seen an Elk. Just ’cause I’ve never witnessed one doesn’t mean they’re not there.

    For your amusement, from the cheesily named Secrets of the Samurai (Adele Westbrook and Oscar Ratti weren’t great writers in my opinion but if like me you’re interested in Aikido you put up with it). Speaking of the Ronin:

    As late as the nineteenth century, the judo master Yokoyama reminisced about an encounter between one of these wandering warriors, “rather shabbily dressed and evidently very poor,” and three young samurai in the Kojimachi ward of Kudan. The younger men forced the ronin to acept their challenge to a duel because his scabbard had inadvertently touched the scabbard of one of the three.

    In accordance with custom the combatants exchanged names and swords were unsheathed, the three samurai on one side facing the solitary opponent with whom the sympathies of the onlookers evidently lay. The keen blades of the duellists glittered in the sun. The ronin, as calm as though engaged in merely in a friendly fencing bout, advanced advanced steadily with the point of his weapon directed against the samurai in the centre of the trio, and apparently indifferent to attack on either flank. The samurai in the middle gave ground inch by inch and the ronin as surely stepped forward. Then the right hand samurai, who thought he saw an opening, rushed to the attack, but the ronin, who had clearly anticipated this move parried and with lightning rapidity cut his enemy down with a mortal blow. The left-hand samurai came on in his turn and but was treated in a similar fashion, a single stroke felling him to the ground bathed in blood. All this took less time than it takes to tell. The samurai in the centre, seeing the fate of his comrades, thought better of his first intention and took to his heels. (Harrison, 71-72)

    The ronin in question then “repaired to the neighboring magistrate’s office to report the occurrence, as the law required.” This in the nineteenth century!

    Ratti/Westbrook 123-124)

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  66. Your slip is showing NK

    If that means I don’t share the mindless hatred of Muslims shown by some here, the answer is “Yes, three clothyards past my knees”.

    nk (dbc370)

  67. i had lunch with my muslim friend today the guy that got me my job what i have now and we went to the halal food carts over in the park where the occupy wall street people were

    they are very famous and beautiful carts of peace and the foozles are very cheap and very very tasty

    very filling lunch plus drink for $6 and it was delectable to where I bet i go back this week

    how America is that?

    very America is how America that is

    happyfeet (a037ad)

  68. I have a mindful contempt for Muslims who have a mindless hate for Americans.

    I have a mindful respect for those Muslims who risked their own lives to aid US forces in the sand box as translators and interpreters.

    I have a mindful contempt for those Americans who aren’t expediting the process of bringing those Muslims here. Where they’d be an asset to this nation.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  69. There could be another Saladin.

    We have to guard against that.

    Overconfidence kills.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  70. Exactly how many buildings need to be bombed, civilians murdered, military bases attacked, consulates and embassies stormed, ships blown up, ambassadors and soldiers murdered, planes hijacked, cripples thrown off ships, Christians beheaded, women stoned, homos hanged, reporters beheaded, children enslaved, women raped, girls mutilated, daughters allowed to drown and marathons bombed before the hatred of moslems is no longer mindless? Or do you believe people who yell “Death to America” and mean it deserve a pizza?

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  71. Hoagie, in a timely manner kishnevi usefully reminds us of the concept of the nom de guerre.

    Abu Bakr al Baghdadi takes his nom de guerre from the first rightly Caliph who took over the Ummah following Muhammad’s death. The first wars he fought were the wars of apostasy.

    There is a reason why he’s crucifying Muslims. And my hatred is not mindless.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  72. His name is no accident.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  73. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ridda_wars

    The Ridda wars (Arabic: حروب الردة), also known as the Wars of Apostasy, were a series of military campaigns launched by the Caliph Abu Bakr against rebel Arabian tribes during 632 and 633 AD, just after Muhammad died.[1] The rebels’ position was that they had submitted to Muhammad as the prophet of God, but owed nothing to Abu Bakr…

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  74. I just find it ridiculous that anybody could think that hatred of moslems is mindless after centuries of their diabolical atrocities perpetrated against all races and religions all over the world. I think one would need to be out of their mind not to hate these b@stards. That’s like not hating Nazi’s or commies after all their death and destruction. You do realize these animals want genocide against the Jews, to wipe Israel off the map and follow that up with The Great Satan, us!

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  75. Hoagie, my elder brother in arms, maybe you would respect Winston Churchill’s opinion.

    I can’t find it as it seems to be available only in book form.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  76. Churchill didn’t have any disregard for individual Muslims.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  77. Geez Dana why don’t you just come out and say what you really think about these morons stuck in the medieval ages? At one point many years ago I was sleeping and heard my younger daughter screaming. I went through a door so hard that the paint transferred to my shirt. I’m a big guy at 6′ 5″ and over 250, and if I found somebody threatening my daughter harm, that person would be dead.

    And as for the father who watched his daughter die because lifeguards couldn’t/shouldn’t touch her–he has the soul of a paramecium.

    Comanche Voter (1d5c8b)

  78. I’m nowhere near that size, Comanche Voter.

    I bet I could have run through that door, though.

    So could my wife, and she’s even smaller, if she suspected her kid was in danger.

    I would not want to be between that door and her.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  79. And I played Rugby. I gave blood.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  80. Dear CV: that comment is not fair to paramecia.

    This comes to mind:

    http://datechguyblog.com/2011/03/03/cultural-imperalism-and-sati-suttee/

    From the link:

    General Charles Napier held the offices of Governor of Bombay and Commander-in-Chief of India for the British Empire,was confronted with the tradition of Sati (or Suttee) where the new widow of a deceased man would be thrown alive on his funeral pyre. Napier forbade it, and when leaders of the community objected saying it was their custom. Napier with all the confidence of an 1850’s Brit with this classic answer (via Mark Steyn’s book America Alone)

    “You say that it is your custom to burn widows. Very well. We also have a custom: when men burn a woman alive, we tie a rope around their necks and we hang them. Build your funeral pyre; beside it, my carpenters will build a gallows. You may follow your custom. And then we will follow ours.”

    Sati or Suttee has been gone from India for 160 years. How many widows did not die in excruciating pain because of this example of “cultural imperialism”?

    Simon Jester (c8876d)

  81. I’ll probably hoist one tonight to cultural imperialism, SJ.

    I’m a big fan.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  82. Saburo Sakai was a big fan of cultural imperialism.

    And I’m a big fan of Saburo Sakai.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  83. http://www.nytimes.com/2000/10/08/world/saburo-sakai-is-dead-at-84-war-pilot-embraced-foes.html

    …Mr. Sakai was dining with American military officers at the Atsugi Naval Air Station west of Tokyo and suffered a heart attack as he leaned across the table to shake hands with an American; he died later in a hospital. ..

    G0ddam. Good egg.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  84. RE: # 66

    Your slip is showing NK

    If that means I don’t share the mindless hatred of Muslims shown by some here, the answer is “Yes, three clothyards past my knees”.

    nk (dbc370) — 8/11/2015 @ 2:22 pm

    No, it means your argument is in bad faith – as is your slander of the good Rev.

    Steve Malynn (6b1ce5)

  85. Saburo Sakai had a little dog named Pepito.

    One day Pepito did not come when Saburo called.

    Saburo was very sad. He feared an evil fate had befallen Pepito.

    Saburo waited many many moons for Pepito to return.

    He waited and he waited.

    And then one day he knew in his heart his sweet little Pepito was no more.

    He went to the back of the house and called for Marisol, the forlorn mate that Pepito had left behind.

    He built a pyre and hurled Marisol upon it and watched her burn.

    And then some British guy hung him by the neck the end.

    happyfeet (5546fb)

  86. That’s a suck @$$ thing to say about Saburo Sakai, feets.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  87. He was a Japanese aviator, I’ll give you that. But still.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  88. when recounting the past one must steer one’s ship by the lodestar of truth Mr. 57

    clio gifts so few of us with her songs

    it is a burden i wear heavily

    happyfeet (5546fb)

  89. But to malign Saburo Sakai.

    To paint that broadly.

    I can’t do it.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  90. it is a sad tale made sadder by the telling

    happyfeet (5546fb)

  91. Ceasar defeated Pompey at Pharsalus. I think he could have defeated aviators like he deveated horsmen.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  92. defeated.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  93. Oh blow me.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  94. Sorry, I hope I dont’t get banned for that. But if I do, it was from the heart.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  95. I found the quote to which you referred on Snopes, Steve57. But my very limited computer skills does not allow me to copy it to Patterico. I just went to Snopes and typed in”Churchill islam” and it came up.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  96. I was at the airplane exhibit at the Museum of Science and Industry, when a group of Japanese tourists came up behind me. I stepped aside to let them through and the oldest looked at me and said, “Sank you”. I said, “Bombed you”. Why can’t some people just let bygones be bygones?

    nk (dbc370)

  97. Steve

    Celebrating someone who strafed our countrymen, our brave marines on the Canal probably isn’t going to garner much sympathy.

    EPWJ (4df1f9)

  98. How far back are you willing to go, EPWJ?

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlie_Brown_and_Franz_Stigler_incident

    I’ll take my chances. I knew a lot of Marines who thought as highly of Saburo Sakai as I did.

    Yeah, back in the ’40s…

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  99. I’m not celebrating someone who strafed our contrymen. I’d never do that. I’m paying respect to a fellow warrior.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  100. Mr 57 wrote:

    And I played Rugby. I gave blood.

    As the bumper sticker said, it takes leather balls to play rugby.

    The amused Dana (1b79fa)

  101. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karl_D%C3%B6nitz

    …Dönitz lived out the rest of his life in relative obscurity in Aumühle, occasionally corresponding with collectors of German Naval history, and died there of a heart attack on 24 December 1980. As the last German officer with the rank of Grand Admiral, he was honoured by many former servicemen and foreign naval officers who came to pay their respects at his funeral on 6 January 1981. The West German government argued he should receive only the pension pay of a captain because all of his advances in rank after that had been because of Hitler, but he won a court case demanding the pension for his final rank. He was buried in Waldfriedhof Cemetery in Aumühle without military honours, and soldiers were not allowed to wear uniforms to the funeral.[37] However a number of German naval officers disobeyed this order and were joined by members of the Royal Navy, such as the senior chaplain the Rev Dr John Cameron, in full dress uniform. Also in attendance were over one hundred holders of the Knight’s Cross of the Iron Cross.[38]

    As the historian evaluating the battle of Tassafaronga noted, it helps to be able to say that the combatant who just handed you your @$$ was really, really good at the profession.

    Raizo Tanaka was good at his job.

    I’m not above or below saying that.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  102. Tameichi Hara observed that American destroyermen did go in for the kill, did go in to torpedo range.

    The darned things just didn’t work.

    They gave credit where credit was due. I don’t see how it helps the cause for me to do less.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  103. http://www.navsource.org/archives/05/0568008.jpg

    The USS Melvin sinks the Fuso, Surigao.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  104. http://www.navweaps.com/index_tech/tech-079.htm

    Performance of US Battleships at Surigao Strait

    by Joseph Czarnecki
    Updated 30 April 2002

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  105. Steve

    They committed atrocities that still reverberate throughout that region, there will always be idiots who pay homage to warriors who killed dutch women and children, defenseless british citizens, who no one in the world felt sorry for them when we had to resort to the unthinkable to get them to stop their decades long rampage through Asia – go for it. I didnt realize you had 28 confirmed kills in your career and are a fellow warrior, please excuse us who think that shooting our fellow americans was an honorable enterprise.

    I appreciate your service and your enthusiasm for our Navy, I don’t appreciate worshiping Nazi criminals or Japanese aces YMMV

    EPWJ (4df1f9)

  106. wasn’t an honorable exercise,

    EPWJ (4df1f9)

  107. EPWJ, don’t you think I don’t know that I know the Japanese committed horrible war crimes?

    I know American vets who still look at the Japanese flag and see the flaming red @$$hole of Japan.

    On the other hand I know Japanese who were really, no kidding, delighted they were defeated. They were just as disgusted at the atrocities as you are.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  108. Up until Midway, some Japanese thought they could beat America. After the defeat they were locked away. The news of the defeat would kill the war effort, they weren’t so much as told.

    I knew a a lot of guys who walked hundreds of miles just so they could surrender to Americans. I’m not ashamed of that.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  109. Steve57

    Some of the old wwII vets will never buy a Japanese car… just like some American Jews whose ancestors endured the holocast will never buy a german car.
    A good friend whose dad was a marine did three amphibious invasions in the Pacific and at the end could not extricate his feelings from hatred for those who killed his friends brutally… so we just worked around it

    steveg (fed1c9)

  110. steveg, like I don’t know this about the WWII vets of the ironically named Pacific War. That I was raised by.

    I appreciate the gentle way you are trying to inform me of the news. But the war is over.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  111. steve57

    Sorry, I don’t follow lines of reasoning from people who worship Nazi monsters or people who call someone their fellow warrior who strafed my countrymen.

    EPWJ (4df1f9)

  112. Oh good Allah

    JD (3b5483)

  113. EPWJ you are out of line re: #111.

    But your hackery is par for the course.

    Steve Malynn (6b1ce5)

  114. “Asian” in this context means Indian, Pakistani, Sri Lanka. It’s not PC, it’s just British. Asia is a big place. In America Asian means “East Asian” and in the UK Asian means “South Asian”.

    I’m not sure if this thread is sort of meandering into an off-topic direction because the “Asian” used to describe the contemptible, deranged father makes some folks immediately think of people from Japan, Korea or China (etc).

    I know when I see or hear “Asian” I tend to think of East Asians and not a populace from farther west around India or Bangladesh. But this is a good example of why the supposedly politically incorrect word of “Oriental” actually does serve a useful, helpful purpose. “Oriental” pretty much is limited to describe people from the general vicinity of Japan/Korea/China, and not people from India, etc.

    Mark (9abec5)

  115. Asian was also the designation used in South Africa and Rhodesia for Indians, like Mohandas Gandhi. And Orient means East – The Near East – The Middle East – Far East.

    ropelight (8383a5)

  116. EPWJ, what is your opinion of the Japanese men who all of a sudden became self defense force officers and ardent American allies when we ended the occupation?

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  117. Hey Maylynn and JD

    Yeah, I forced ole 57 to write about Donitz and Nazi worship on a thread about something totally different

    my bad…

    EPWJ (4df1f9)

  118. Orita Zenji? You have an opinion on him?

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  119. Steve57

    They never were our allies, they are not our allies now. They still commit crimes against American business an block our goods from their country while demanding more unfettered access to ours,

    but then again its difficult to reason with war hero samurai wannabes who also think women cant serve their country?

    EPWJ (4df1f9)

  120. @117, you forced yourself into proving you are a d***.

    I know you don’t know, but Orita Zenji retired as a Captain in the JMSDF in 1964. He was a fleet submarine commander in WWII. I am grateful my father did not run across him. I would rather have him on my side than any ten people you could name.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  121. Steve57

    keep backtracking works, I think the posting of Donitz article was off the wall, highly inadvised and isn’t going to help any case you are trying to make, I will blame the unhanged filters at the Coors plant for this bizarre sidetrack and quick trip to the sewer..

    Tomorrow will be better.

    EPWJ (4df1f9)

  122. …They never were our allies, they are not our allies now…

    Yes, they are. How many years did you spend with them?

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  123. @121, does anyone other then EPWJ think I’m backtracking?

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  124. Steve57

    go to bed, get some rest and I would recommend thinking first about calling people who killed Americans my fellow warrior, when we right now are having a national discussion about Iran, enemies etc and as a pro tip, submarines killed hundreds of American women and children in two wars and were the enemy they don’t sell Donitz plushy toys at the Chicago Museum of S&I

    EPWJ (4df1f9)

  125. Oh dear Lord. It’s happening again.

    Simon Jester (264b91)

  126. EPWJ, I will go to bed in the full knowledge this isn’t even a debate.

    Nimitz slept well knowing that his officers would learn from the lesson the Japanese had taught them.

    Thank God he didn’t have p****s like you.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  127. I was a Nipponphile in my younger days. But the more you get past the childhood gloss of something into the reality of it, the less you like it. The Japanese were just like any other militaristic, feudal society controlled by murderers, rapists and thieves which is what the samurai were.

    Our soldiers in WWII had their number. We had about 350,000 German soldiers in POW camps in the USA. We had hardly any Japanese. Now, it’s likely true that Japanese soldiers were under orders not to be captured and took those orders to heart. But I’m guessing that our soldiers did not try very hard to get them to surrender, either. Not after Pearl Harbor and the Phillipines, and the revelations about their atrocities in China and Southeast Asia.

    nk (dbc370)

  128. http://www.amazon.com/Rising-Sun-Pacific-1931-April-1942/dp/159114549X/ref=la_B000APLTPK_1_2?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1439383921&sr=1-2

    The Rising Sun in the Pacific, 1931-April 1942: History of United States Naval Operations in World War II, Volume 3 (History of the United States Naval Operations in World War II) Paperback – March 15, 2010
    by Samuel Eliot Morison (Author), H. P. Willmott (Introduction)

    …It is always some consolation to reflect that the enemy who defeats you defeats you is really good, and Rear Admiral Tanaka was better than that–he was superb. Without his trusted flagship Jintsu, his decks cluttered with supplies, he sank a heavy cruiser and put three others out of action for nearly a year, at the cost of one destroyer. In many actions of the war, mistakes on the American side were cancelled by those of the enemy: but despite the brief confusion of his destroyers Tanaka made no mistakes at Tassafaronga.

    http://www.comandosupremo.com/italian-folgore-at-el-alamein-unbreakable.html

    …During the battle of Alam El Hafla, the Italian Airborne Division Folgore (185.a Divisione Paracadutisti “Folgore”) had been positioned to guard the left flank of the German 90th Light Division and the Ramcke Brigade, and was successful in driving off an attack by New Zealand Infantry during a fierce encounter between the 3rd and 4th of September. The performance by the Italians in this clash was greatly respected by their German allies, so much so that Wehrmacht leaders awarded 11 Iron Crosses to Folgore soldiers for their heroics on the battlefield. When news reached Montgomery on the outcome of the encounter, he became angered that his forces had been ‘thrashed’ by Italians, a fact that he no doubt found unacceptable.

    Shortly after this engagement, a Folgore patrol captured Brigadier General G.H. Clifton, commander of the New Zealand 6th Brigade, who while scouting mistakenly drove his vehicle into the midst of a group of Folgore soldiers. They immediately took him and several of his aides captive at gun point. During his subsequent interrogation by Rommel, General Clifton requested to be sent for confinement at a German POW camp instead of an Italian one, for he felt both angry and embarrassed at being captured by Italians. Rommel at first agreed, but after Clifton attempted an escape during a German interrogation, Rommel’s decision was countermanded, and the General was shipped to Italy for internment…

    …The Allies surrounded or smashed some of the forward Italian positions at the onset of their attack, but were stifled as they approached the main line of the Italian defense. The fighting raged into the early morning of the 24th as each side fought hard in this ferocious encounter. The Italian Folgore would hold its ground and proved victorious with the attackers only able to gain a minimal amount of ground.

    …Throughout the battle of Second El Alamein, a tank group from the German 21st Panzer Division, along with elements of the Ariete Armoured Division, had stood by in the rear behind the Folgore to act as a reserve in order to counter any British breakthrough that might occur. The Folgore never had need to call upon them during the entire battle as they had proved more than a match against the Allied units.

    The British 132st Infantry Brigade/44th Inf.Div, and French forces were once more repelled on the 27th, and operations against the Italians were temporarily halted as the British military leadership reluctantly conceded that despite the fact that they held a numerical superiority in almost every category over their adversary, they could not defeat the Folgore in this sector with the forces they had so far employed.

    …Colonel Camosso ordered his surrounded soldiers to destroy their weapons before the surrender, for he wanted nothing of material value to fall into the enemy’s hands. As it became apparent to the British that the Folgore was no longer resisting, they advanced forward to secure the enemy they had come to respect over these many days of hard battle. Upon making contact with the Italians, the British were once again impressed by the sight they found, for there was not a single white flag of surrender held by the Folgore, nor did they find men clamoring for aid or comfort from the victors. What the British did discover waiting for them were warriors standing at ridged attention with their arms at their sides, staring resolutely forward, defeated but not bowed.

    On November 7th the commander of the British 44th Infantry Division, General Hughes, made an effort to meet with the Folgore’s commander, General Frattini. General Hughes men had suffered a high number of casualties against the Folgore, and the Allied General had been more then impressed with the resilience and skill of his adversary. Upon finding General Frattini amongst the captured Folgore, he saluted and expressed the highest of praise for the Folgore’s gallantry in combat. General Frattini replied with a simple “Thank you”, for what more could be said…

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  129. “Oriental” pretty much is limited to describe people from the general vicinity of Japan/Korea/China, and not people from India, etc.

    That would mean oriental rugs come from Japan/Korea/China. Perhaps knock-offs but not the real McCoy’s.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  130. japanese add value

    just a tremendous amount of value

    plus they make the sex robots

    happyfeet (a037ad)

  131. Heh! Oriental rugs should be called Caucasian. They come from Armenia, Azerbaijan, Iran and Turkey which the Caucasus mountains run through. The better ones, anyway.

    nk (dbc370)

  132. The better rugs, not the better mountains.

    nk (dbc370)

  133. http://www.naval-history.net/xGM-Chrono-01BB-Valiant.htm

    December

    At Alexandria.

    18th – (At approximate1840 hours the Italian submarine SCIRE arrived in a position about a mile west of the entrance to Alexandria harbour. At 2047 hours three SLC (Siluro Lenta Corsa = Slow moving torpedo), known as Maiale (Italian word for pigs) with a top speed of 2knots submerged and a range of 15 miles, were launched from SCIRE. Each Maiale carried two commandos from the 10th flotilla MAS, after launching they headed for the harbour entrance. When they arrived at the harbour entrance they found the anti-submarine boom open for the passage of the cruisers and destroyers returning from escorting the BRECONSHIRE to Malta. The three Maiales followed the British forces into Alexandria harbour and headed for their targets the battleships QUEEN ELIZABETH, VALIANT and a fleet oiler. The VALIANT was the target of the Maiale, SLC 221, manned by Durand De La Penne and Emilio Bianchi. )

    19th – At approximately 0230 hours Durand De La Penne and Emilio Bianchi placed the explosive warhead of the Maiale, which was a standard 270 kg torpedo warhead, filled with TNT, on the harbour bottom underneath the VALIANT.
    At 0325 hours Durand De La Penne and Emilio Bianchi were sighted sitting on VALIANT’s mooring buoy and were taken aboard the VALIANT, where they were questioned, but refused to answer any questions. They were detained in a compartment on board VALIANT until 0600 hours when De La Penne asked to speak to VALIANT’s CO, Captain Morgan. De La Penne informed Morgan that the device they had planted was due to explode imminently. De La Penne was then returned to the compartment.
    At 0547 hours an explosive device went off under the stern of the oiler MV SAGONA 7554grt, at the time of the explosion the SAGONA had four destroyers alongside refuelling, one of which, the JERVIS, was also damaged by the explosion.
    At 0606 hours the explosive device went off under VALIANT’s A turret, causing flooding and serious damage to VALIANT.
    At 0610 hours an explosive device went off under the QUEEN ELIZABETH.
    Both VALIANT and QUEEN ELIZABETH settled on the harbour bottom on an even keel in a few feet of water.

    (The other four commandos failed to escape and were also captured. At a stroke the six commandos had knocked out the Royal Navy’s Mediterranean Battle Fleet. When Churchill received news of the sinkings he said, ‘Six Italians, dressed in rather unusual diving suits and equipped with materials of laughably little cost, have swung the military balance of power in the Mediterranean in favour of the Axis’. Fortunately for the Allies the enemy was not fully aware of the precarious position of the Mediterranean Fleet. One reason being that the British allowed photographs of the seemingly undamaged battleships to appear in the British press.)

    Captain Morgan, RN, the CO of the Valiant recommended Luigi Durand De La Penne, Regia Marina, La Decima Flottiglia MAS, for a medal, so impressed was he with the Axis Nazi Fascist Italian mofo’s gallantry.

    The history doesn’t report what compartment the English were holding him in. It was below the waterline, just above the keel. They couldn’t find the mine, and they wanted to make sure the Italian died with the ship.

    De La Penne was OK with going down with the Valiant, the ship he had mined. But he asked to speak to the Captain only to let him know he had just enough time to get his crew to safety.

    Then he went back.

    The Royal Navy wisely came to the conclusion that it would set a bad example to start giving out medals to the enemy for displaying big brass cajones in combat against the Royal Navy. So thus far you have agreement, EPWJ. But they still couldn’t help but respect the man.

    After Italy changed sides, CAPT. Morgan attended the award ceremony for his former enemy, when the King of Italy presented the equivalent of the Victoria Cross/Medal of Honor to LT. De La Penne.

    Who was a hard man to stop.

    You are totally f***ed in the head, EPWJ.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  134. admiration for japanese culture has little to do with criticism of the Shinto Control faction,

    http://therightscoop.com/ex-intel-chief-reveals-obama-knew-in-2012-potential-for-isis-rise-funded-rebels-anyway/

    narciso (ee1f88)

  135. EPWJ @111:

    …Sorry, I don’t follow lines of reasoning from people who worship Nazi monsters or people who call someone their fellow warrior who strafed my countrymen…

    Aren’t we lucky the professionals don’t take this attitude?

    The Italian Tenth Light Flotilla pioneered naval special warfare. The SEALs aren’t shy about saying so. I’m sorry my attitude bothers you. Have you ever been in a fight?

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  136. sad that steve continues his admiration for people who kill americans

    EPWJ (4df1f9)

  137. Count Borghese, like certain Vichy counterparts like Bousquet, certainly avoided most purges of that era,
    the fact that would come to bite us in the 70s.

    narciso (ee1f88)

  138. o by your standards the pilots on 9/11? are you a “fellow” warrior? You realize that when the two battleships went down more men in the merchant marine died from lack of escort right?

    Really stop admiring people who killed Americans and their friends – its a loser

    EPWJ (4df1f9)

  139. yes, he’s gone full sharknado to evade the point

    narciso (ee1f88)

  140. consider the fact that Abe’s grandfather Kishi was a class A war criminal, yet because he was part of the LDP’s key founders with Sasagawa, rose to top leadership in a generation,

    narciso (ee1f88)

  141. nk @127, the Japanese were under orders not to surrender. It was a court martial offense. Late in the war the Japanese high command tried to reverse those orders. They ordered their troops to surrender, to try and avoid the waste of lives.

    It didn’t do as much good as they hoped.

    I am unsure of EPWJ’s point, other than knowing if I’m on one side he has to be on the other.

    Am I not supposed to respect my enemy? Am I not supposed to learn from my enemy?

    I can track the development of European swords and trace back just how they changed based upon combat with the Muslims.

    Damascus steel, anyone?

    Or am I not supposed to think of my enemy as human? I thought that was one of the criticisms of the military mindset. That we simplistically dehumanized the enemy, in order to make it easier to kill them.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  142. Forget it Steve57. You and I have fought in battle and killed men in battle. Trying to explain the respect one has for a brave fellow warrior to a person ignorant of what that means is impossible. I think EPWJ is equating respect for valor with admiration of the enemy’s intent. If you’ve not been there you probably won’t understand.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  143. one of the signs of malpractice was how McArthur scapegoates Yamashitas, for the sins committed by Princes who were really responsible for events in Manila,

    narciso (ee1f88)

  144. Steve57

    try understanding the loss, suffered even today, honoring those who killed their loved ones isn’t going to be a winner, I don’t think you were ever in combat correct? There’s a whole set of emotions from intense conflicts that an army of psychologists are till typing on a million keyboards trying to figure it out.

    Forgiving an enemy is one thing, a good thing, admiring them for their bravery in committing atrocities and killing americans is another

    EPWJ (4df1f9)

  145. likewise we deal with the Khalifas and other dynasties in the Gulf, because even though they may have provided support to a whole host of Salafis in the past, they none the less are threatened by them,

    narciso (ee1f88)

  146. Brother Hoagie, you give me too much credit. I trained for combat. I trained for damage control.

    I trained to fight my way out if a VBSS turned from compliant to hostile/opposed.

    Probably because we did all that training, visibly so, nobody was stupid enough to test us. I hope you don’t think less of me. I never killed anyone. People just stayed out of our way. Sometimes you have to fight for maritime supremacy. We achieved it just by being there.

    What I learned from our nation’s enemies is that nothing less than perfection will do.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  147. EPWJ, I honestly don’t understand who you think you are dealing with. My dad was a Coastie stationed on Luzon at the end of WWII. His job, not assigned to him by the USCG, was to take pictures of the graves of the sons of friends of the family.

    I know about the suffering. What, again, is your point?

    There were Japanese who were real b@st@ards. I hope we killed them all.

    But if my dad could get over his problem with the Japanese, why can’t you?

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  148. Well, Steve57, I was just sayin’ it’s hard to understand how enemies can respect each other’s bravery and valor under fire if you’ve not been. I want to assure EPWJ I don’t admire an enemy for committing atrocities or killing Americans. But I am able to see the valor in an enemy when he faces me. I fought with some very brave Americans in Nam and I can assure you we faced an enemy with men just as valiant. I killed them, but I understood them. I’m sure there were brave Nazi’s. I can honor his bravery without admiring his being a damn Nazi. Hell, they actually paid me to kill commies. Best job ever.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  149. Just saying, brother Hoagie, I operated on the principle that my enemy was training every day so I needed to as well. Nothing but my best would do.

    Along those lines, and I would like to hear EPWJ’s opinion.

    The IJN I-58 sank the USS Indianapolis of “Jaws” fame at 12:14 a.m. on 30 July 1945. CAPT McVay was convicted during a post war court martial despite the fact that the skipper of the I-58, Hashimoto Mochitsura, testified mostly in favor of the defense. He had lined up for what amounted to a pistol shot for a submarine with a long lance, and was saying to himself “This ship is dead, this ship is dead.”

    Which in itself isn’t so unusual, but the unusual part happened after the war at the court martial.

    The USN dragged Hashimoto into court to testify because they were trying to hang McVay (this is part of the reason I responded to Milhouse about embarrassing themselves never stopped the brass before). Hashimoto was confused and disgusted. He couldn’t understand why his former enemy was calling him into a court martial to testify against a USN officer. He thought that was the lowest thing imaginable.

    I agree with him.

    So, am I an enemy of the all that is decent for agreeing with Hashimoto and looking down on the naval officers who thought this was a smart thing to do?

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  150. http://www.history.navy.mil/research/histories/oral-histories/wwii/interrogation-of-cdr-hashimoto-co-of-i-58.html

    1. [Question] Were the exploders (devices used to initiate the explosion of the [torpedo] warhead) used in the torpedoes fired at the U.S.S. Indianapolis a German or a Japanese development?

    [Answer] The exploders were Japanese-built, but Hashimoto did not know whether or not of German or Japanese design. (Description indicates this to be a copy of the German Pi 3).

    2. [Question] If German, what was the German name for this exploder?

    [Answer] No answer.

    3. [Question] Was it necessary for these torpedoes to strike the ship in order for the exploder to function?
    [Answer] Impact is not necessary for the exploder to function.

    4. [Question] If not, how far below the keel of the ship could the torpedo pass and still fire?

    [Answer] The torpedo could pass below the ship a maximum of 4 meters and still fire.

    5. [Question] Were your instructions for depth setting on torpedoes carrying a magnetic exploder the same as those for torpedoes carrying a contact exploder only?

    [Answer] No, the instructions were different. Magnetics were fired on deeper settings.

    6. [Question] Is it true that the torpedoes fired at the U.S.S. Indianapolis carried exploders that were actuated by the magnetic field of the ship?

    [Answer] Yes.

    7. [Question] When you fired these torpedoes did you choose a depth setting which would permit the exploders to operate magnetically?

    [Answer] According to Hashimoto there was no time to make a more suitable setting. Consequently it was left as it was, at 4 meters.

    8. [Question] Did the torpedoes carry a mechanical exploder which would operate on contact with the ship as well as the magnetic exploder?

    [Answer] The torpedoes carried combination magnetic and impact exploders.

    9. [Question] Was there any other reason for choosing the depth setting used than that of exploder performance? If so, what was the reason or reasons?

    [Answer] See #7.

    10. [Question] Do you believe that the torpedoes which sank the U.S.S. Indianapolis did so by striking the ship before exploding?

    [Answer] Yes.

    11. [Question] If not, how far below the ship do you believe the explosions occurred?

    [Answer] No answer.

    12. [Question] Could you see well enough through the periscope to tell whether the torpedoes exploded on the near or the far side of the ship? If so, describe where you believe they exploded.

    [Answer] Yes, the torpedoes hit the near side of the ship.

    13. [Question] What did you estimate the draft of the U.S.S. Indianapolis to be?

    [Answer] 7 meters. Hashimoto believed his target to be an old-style BB [US battleship].

    14. [Question] If the exploders used against the Indianapolis were not magnetically operated, what was their operating principal? (Acoustic, electromagnetic, electric.)

    [Answer] They were combination magnetic and impact.

    15. [Question] How many pockets were provided in the torpedo to house various parts of the exploder? Where were they located?

    [Answer] There were two pockets, the magnetic one in the nose of the torpedo and the impact on the top. The impact exploder was believed by Hashimoto to be an inertia type (pendulum).

    16. [Question] Did the exploders used against the Indianapolis require any maintenance aboard the submarine? Explain.

    [Answer] There was no maintenance aboard.

    17. [Question] Did the exploders require any servicing upon return from a war patrol? Explain.

    [Answer] Probably.

    18. [Question] Did you have torpedoes aboard equipped with exploders of any other type? Why didn’t you use them?

    [Answer] There were no torpedoes of any other exploder-type aboard. All were combination magnetic and impact, except the KAITENS which were impact only.

    19. [Question] Did you ever have torpedoes equipped with an external towed devised for controlling or exploding the torpedo?

    [Answer] Hashimoto never used such devices, but was familiar with them.

    20. [Question] Do you consider the towed exploding device satisfactory? If not, why not?

    [Answer] Hashimoto considers the device no good.

    21. [Question] Did you ever have trouble with torpedoes exploding before they reached the target? What type of exploders did this?

    [Answer] Both magnetic and impact exploders are subject to premature explosions. The reason for this was never cleared up properly, but magnetics were almost sure to premature in a rough sea.

    22. [Question] Did you have any instructions regarding the minimum safe depth for firing torpedoes with special exploders? What were they? What was the minimum safe depth?

    [Answer] The minimum safe depth was 1½ meters.

    23. [Question] Did you have trouble with torpedoes coming out of water in a rough sea and firing before they should have?

    [Answer] Hashimoto stated they had little trouble with torpedoes coming out of the water (but see #21 above).

    24. [Question] What were the special instructions for firing the torpedo due to the use of the magnetic exploder? Was it necessary to know the size of the [target] ship, material of ship construction, ship’s heading, latitude, etc.?

    [Answer] There were no special instructions as regards ship’s heading or latitude, but depth settings for magnetics were deeper.

    25. [Question] What material is the [torpedo] warhead made of?

    [Answer] Probably steel.

    26. [Question] How far must the torpedo run before the exploder can operate? Is this distance the same for all types of exploders? Explain.

    [Answer] The torpedo must run from 300 to 500 meters. Hashimoto did not remember exact information on this subject.

    27. [Question] Was it necessary to stop the submarine screws [propeller] before or immediately after firing torpedoes with any type of exploder you have used?

    [Answer] It was not necessary to stop the screws.

    28. [Question] How long has the magnetic exploder used on the Indianapolis been in use?

    [Answer] It has been in use since the middle of 1944.

    29. [Question] Where was it manufactured?

    [Answer] It was manufactured in Kure.

    30. [Question] Did ships’ noise influence its operation?

    [Answer] The ships’ noise did not influence its operation.

    31. [Question] Under what conditions would magnetic or other non-contact exploders not have been used?

    [Answer] Magnetics would not be used in a rough sea.

    32. [Question] Was there more than one type of non-contact exploder in use? Describe the significant features of each type.

    [Answer] There was no more than one type, i.e. the magnetic.

    33. [Question] Under what conditions would you use a non-contact exploder? Under what conditions would you use a contact exploder?

    [Answer] Contact exploders are generally preferred, especially in rough seas, because of the possibility of premature explosions in the magnetics. The submarines are usually loaded about half and half of each kind of exploder torpedoes. Also many sub commanders lacked confidence in the magnetic exploder and used the impact exploders at all times.

    34. [Question] What is the recommended time interval between successive shots in a spread?

    [Answer] 3 seconds.

    35. [Question] What type of exploder do you believe was most effective in sinking ships? Why?

    [Answer] Relatively few magnetics were used. Hashimoto personally was very favorable to magnetics except in rough seas.

    36. [Question] What weight of explosive material was used in torpedo warheads fired at the Indianapolis?

    [Answer] Although he was not certain, Hashimoto thought the weight was 550 kilograms [approximately 1,210 lbs].

    37. [Question] What is the composition of the explosive material?

    [Answer] It is Shimose powder.

    38. [Question] Have you fired torpedoes with aluminum included in the composition of the explosive?

    [Answer] Hashimoto is not familiar with the composition of explosives.

    39. [Question] Have you noticed any significant difference in damage resulting from the use of different weights or compositions of explosive material? Explain.

    [Answer] Hashimoto has not noticed any notable difference.

    40. [Question] Could any submarine fire the non-contact type torpedoes. If not, what types could?

    [Answer] All types could fire the non-contact torpedoes.

    41. [Question] Were non-contact exploders used in aircraft torpedoes?

    [Answer] No answer. (Lack of information].

    42. [Question] How many tail fins did the torpedoes fired at the Indianapolis have?

    [Answer] Four.

    43. [Question] Fill out the following table concerning torpedoes carried on your last cruise:

    [Answer]
    Torpedo Type: Oxygen
    Torpedo Designation: 95
    Warhead Designation: 95 Magnetic
    Exploder Designation: Magnetic No. 5, Impact No. 2

    44. [Question] Did Japanese submarines use torpedoes of German design?

    [Answer] No information.

    45. [Question] Were German ideas used in the design of Japanese torpedoes?

    [Answer] No information.

    46. [Question] Did any electrically-driven torpedoes reach service use? What was its range and speed?

    [Answer] Very few electrically-driven torpedoes reached service use. Range and speed are 7000 meters and 28 knots.

    47. [Question] When did Japanese submarines first employ torpedoes powered with fuel and oxygen?

    [Answer] In 1940.

    48. [Question] How many different types of fuel-oxygen torpedoes were used?

    [Answer] Three (93, 95, 97).

    49. [Question] What was the speed and range of each type?

    [Answer]
    93 – 45 knots – 9000 meters
    95 – 48 knots – 5000 meters
    97 – no information.

    50. [Question] How much was known about the German Ingolin torpedo? Were any of them used against the U.S. Navy?

    [Answer] Nothing.

    51. [Question] Were you troubled with accidental oxygen explosions? What precautions were necessary?

    [Answer] In the early days of the war the [Japanese] were troubled with accidental oxygen explosions. However, fuel and oil were kept away from the oxygen until the last minute. Every effort was made to avoid heat.

    52. [Question] What types of fuel were used with the oxygen torpedo? What form was the oxygen supply? Liquid or gas?

    [Answer] Coal-oil was used with the oxygen torpedo. The oxygen supply was in gas form.

    53. [Question] How much was known about American torpedoes? Name various types known, together with their significant properties.

    [Answer] Nothing was known regarding American torpedoes in this case.

    54. [Question] What accuracy of steering was realized on Japanese torpedoes?

    [Answer] Regarding steering, at 5500 meters, deviation is not over 200 meters.

    55. [Question] Were any Japanese torpedoes equipped wit special figure run devices? Explain.

    [Answer] No.

    56. [Question] Are there any types of Japanese torpedoes that follow the target even though they are not aimed at the target?

    [Answer] No.

    57. [Question] If yes, what method was used to make them follow the target (acoustic, magnetic, electric, electromagnetic)?

    [No response necessary]

    58. [Question] Did these target-seeking torpedoes receive steering signals directly from the ship or from reflection of a searching signal transmitted by the torpedo itself?

    [No response necessary]

    59. [Question] When did target-seeking torpedoes come into general use by Japanese submarines?

    [No response necessary]

    60. [Question] Under what conditions were human torpedoes used? How many did each submarine carry? Was the operator expendable?

    [Answer] Human torpedoes were used if target was out of range of other torpedoes and sometimes in order to avoid detection. Big subs carried 6 human torpedoes; 300-Type carried 3; I-Type carried 2. The operator was 100% expendable. KAITENS were about 1/3 successful. Hashimoto’s only success with them was on the I-58 which sank a U.S. escort carrier (converted) near Guam in January 1945. He observed through the periscope that one hit out of the four launched.

    61. [Question] Which type of torpedo was best liked by Japanese submarine commanders? Why? Was it responsible for most sinkings?

    [Answer] Most Japanese submarine commanders preferred impact-type exploders. Human torpedoes were only used as emergency weapons.

    62. [Question] How were torpedoes launched from Japanese submarines (compressed air, powder charge)?

    [Answer] Torpedoes were launched by compressed air.

    63. [Question] What steps were taken to prevent detection due to air or gas escaping from tubes after launching?

    [Answer] Valves for return of air were used.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  151. Steve57

    Really, I would drop it, romanticizing those who killed Americans duty bound or not, isn’t a winner. Historians in the 1960’s tried to write about Japan, they were not well received as those who wrote about Rommel or other german generals but note that few even today write about the SS commanders why you keep insisting on this line I don’t know but apparently its not something superficial, you have some deep emotional ties – good luck to you working it out. The Pacific war was personal we were betrayed by an Ally who had for a decade subjugated much of Asia. Note that few write about the North Koreans, the Vietnamese, the Chinese war commanders who executed and tortured our captured soldiers. Not that many write about the Japanese commanders as well.

    EPWJ (4df1f9)

  152. I saw a segment about Dusan Popov, the German double agent who discovered Italian prototypes of the armament that was used as Pearl and had warned Hoover,

    narciso (ee1f88)

  153. …I don’t know but apparently its not something superficial, you have some deep emotional ties…

    I asked for orders to Spain, I got Japan.

    I’m still thinking I would have liked Spain better.

    I’m just dragging this out to let you fully illustrate the fact you are a f***tard.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  154. ah just more CYA:

    The Indianapolis sent distress calls before sinking. Three stations received the signals; however, none acted upon the call. One commander was drunk, another had ordered his men not to disturb him and a third thought it was a Japanese trap.[18] For a long time the Navy denied that a distress call had been sent. The receipt of the call came to light only after the release of declassified records.

    narciso (ee1f88)

  155. McVay was scapegoated, narciso. The evidence, had it been declassified, would have cleared him.

    But I note EPWJ can not answer a direct question.

    Hashimoto felt himself defiled by the fact the Navy was using him to railroad one of it’s own officers.

    Who was the better man? One of the US Navy guys, who was attempting to screw McVay?

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  156. She wasn’t zig zagging because the USN didn’t designate those to be torpedo waters.

    The failure reached a lot higher than CAPT McVay, and so the Navy needed a fall guy.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jMl1NbR0h_A

    QUINT’S USS INDIANAPOLIS SPEECH

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  157. http://www.japan-talk.com/jt/new/asakusa-samba-carnival

    2015 Asakusa Samba Carnival Guide…

    I did learn to like Japan, even though it wasn’t Spain.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  158. EPWJ, I take it as given that since you won’t answer my direct question, you are conceding I am right.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  159. Steve57 — For those who know, no explanation is needed; for those who do not, no explanation is possible.

    htom (4ca1fa)

  160. htom, wise words.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  161. As are Hoagie’s.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  162. Today is the traditional Last Day of Summer for Koreans. So even though June is actually in Korea I have an unexpected house full of Asian friends all running around with a half ton of food. Spring rolls, kim-chee jjigae, bulgogi, bibbimbap, gimbap and ox bone soup. Bless their little hearts, they brought pizza for the round-eyes!

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  163. I don’t know why anyone would choose pizza if bibbimbap or bulgogi was on offer.

    Although I could see it happening if someone offered me kegogi.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  164. Is it Karubi or Kalubi?

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  165. Oh, I eat it all Steve57. I even gnaw the kegogi bones. That’s how I keep my “Jabba-The-Hut” figure.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  166. Specially since they got the pizza at Cosco. A great pizzeria on every corner in Philly and they go to Cosco. Damn foreigners.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  167. I’ll pass on the kegogi. Kamsahamnida. Call me a sentimentalist.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  168. Does no one question this story? It doesn’t make sense, and we’re missing details.

    It sounds like it’s an old story from many years ago. It also sounds fishy. Guy says he doesn’t want two lifeguards to go after her? He can’t stop two of them. The two lifeguards were near her in deep water and the guy, what, outswims them? No names, no nothing. I call shenanigans.

    There’s plenty of abhorrent activities by plenty of people; I’m not saying awful things haven’t happened. I’m saying I don’t buy the story that this happened this way.

    JRM (de6363)

  169. The story was reported at AFP (via MSN). The report says the father was arrested, which is some comfort. But The Guardian says it’s an anecdotal report from 1996. As The Guardian says, it must have been a slow news day.

    DRJ (1dff03)

  170. Aren’t all muslim males supposed to know how to swim and ride a horse, the better to attack the infidel?

    Ray Van Dune (2e0c50)

  171. Ray, not only can’t they ride or swim, most of them have never read the Quran.

    Steve57 (5a07a9)

  172. I thought they learned how to swim and ride so they could play water polo.

    Rev. Barack Hussein Hoagie (f4eb27)

  173. .

    The religious of peace indeed…. The peace of the grave.

    .

    IGotBupkis, "Si tacuisses, philosophus mansisses." (225d0d)


Powered by WordPress.

Page loaded in: 0.1427 secs.