Obama Concedes on Health Care Reform? (Updated)
[Guest post by DRJ]
The AP reports President Obama’s comments last night, coming on the same day Republican Senator Scott Brown was sworn in, may signal that health care reform is DOA:
“I think it’s very important for us to have a methodical, open process over the next several weeks, and then let’s go ahead and make a decision,” Obama said at a Democratic National Committee fundraiser.
“And it may be that … if Congress decides we’re not going to do it, even after all the facts are laid out, all the options are clear, then the American people can make a judgment as to whether this Congress has done the right thing for them or not,” the president said. “And that’s how democracy works. There will be elections coming up, and they’ll be able to make a determination and register their concerns.”
It was a shift in tone for the issue the “Yes we can” candidate campaigned on and made the centerpiece of his domestic agenda last year. In a speech to a joint session of Congress in September, Obama declared: “I am not the first president to take up this cause, but I am determined to be the last. … Here and now we will meet history’s test.”
There were varied responses to Obama’s statements:
“Some party activists saw Obama’s remarks as a signal that he’s pulling back from that idea. Others said he may simply be making a last overture to Republicans before using the muscular partisan strategy in the Senate.”
Speaker Pelosi doesn’t seem to be giving up, instead calling on Democratic activists to exert renewed pressure on national politicians to pass reform:
“House Speaker Nancy Pelosi sought momentum in a speech Friday to Democratic Party activists meeting in Washington. “Standing together and working together, we will pass health care reform for the American people,” said Pelosi, D-Calif.
“But recognize your role in this. We can do all the inside maneuvering and legislating and the rest, but without the outside mobilization, without your participation, nothing really great or good can happen.”
David Plouffe does not want to surrender on health care reform, and his recent return to White House tells me it’s folly for the AP to think Obama is conceding now.
The Democrats are still driving this bus. Which road will they take?
— DRJ
UPDATE— MSNBC’s Lawrence O’Donnell says the Democrats have given up on health care reform and this is just posturing to please the liberal base:
“But since Election Night, he said, Democrats have moved into “full bluff mode.”
“We’re absolutely in full fake cheerleading mode. I think Nancy Pelosi has absolutely no moves left. I think she knows that now. I think Harry Reid knows that. And that’s why they don’t bring it up,” he said. “They had a Senate leadership press conference (Thursday) and it was as if (reporters) were asking about World War I” when they asked about reform.
O’Donnell attributes the theatrics to the need to deal with a liberal base that will go bonkers if Democrats quit on reform. And the cue cards are nothing new. He pointed to Democratic Sen. Chuck Schumer’s statements during the fall that the Senate would pass the public option even though “he’s smart enough to know they were never going to get it.”
“No one who went on television was free to say anything realistic,” he said.
***
This time, Democratic leaders are publicly acknowledging that they can’t see the way forward.“I’ve never heard leadership admit publicly to being so lost,” O’Donnell said. “In ’94, we never admitted we didn’t know how to proceed after we crashed and burned in the Senate. We kept up a much better mirage.”
They can either drive into the ditch or call the Motor Club. The choice is between political extinction vs. survival.
Dmac (539341) — 2/5/2010 @ 4:00 pmThey had a full year in which they controlled both houses of congress completely.
And they couldn’t do it.
The epitome of incompetence.
SPQR (26be8b) — 2/5/2010 @ 4:06 pmMy take is he’s trying to pass the blame to Congress, washing his hands of it. Trying to keep whatever base he’s got remaining. Pelosi will love that.
jodetoad (7a7b8a) — 2/5/2010 @ 4:17 pmLet the states handle the issue- as Massachussetts, Maine, and Tennessee had done.
Michael Ejercito (526413) — 2/5/2010 @ 4:22 pmLet the states handle the issue- as Massachussetts, Maine, and Tennessee had done.
Michael Ejercito (526413) — 2/5/2010 @ 4:22 pmI think the Democrats are turning to ‘who shot the Democrat party’?
bill-tb (541ea9) — 2/5/2010 @ 4:48 pmI think he’s satisfied that he can crush our little country by other means is all that this is to say.
happyfeet (713679) — 2/5/2010 @ 5:41 pm“Which road will they take?”
The one off the cliff, of course. They never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity. After having failed for 12 months with super majorities in both chambers and their version of reform becoming increasing unpopular and their words not trusted, now is exactly the time for them to get serious. Heh!
daleyrocks (718861) — 2/5/2010 @ 5:50 pmthe one that will get them to the crossroads at midnight, where they can bury this bullshit once and for all, with a stake through it’s heart.
redc1c4 (fb8750) — 2/5/2010 @ 6:20 pm“The Democrats are still driving this bus. Which road will they take?”
They’ll take the road less trampled, but send the rest of the country off down… Tobacco Road.
GeneralMalaise (55c598) — 2/5/2010 @ 6:39 pmThe bill died on Pork(chop) Hill.
chris (7385e1) — 2/5/2010 @ 7:43 pmBO is a corpseman now.
“then the American people can make a judgment as to whether this Congress has done the right thing for them or not”
That sounds to me like he’s preparing to make the same weird argument he made after the Massachusetts election – that the voters’ rejection of Democrats next fall will actually be because the people wanted health care all along.
Gesundheit (6acc51) — 2/5/2010 @ 7:50 pmBetween tossing friends and family under the bus and driving the bus over the cliff–that is one busy operator.
BfC (5209ec) — 2/5/2010 @ 8:19 pm[…] cries “uncle” finally! and Schizophrenia Or Bald Faced Lying? Patterico’s Pontifications: Obama Concedes on Health Care Reform? (Updated) The Anchoress: Evil Tax Cuts & Humpty Words CNN Money: Urban Unemployment […]
My “Barack Roundup”: George F. Will, Ann Coulter, Charles Krauthammer, Tony Blankley Weigh in on POTUS « Frugal Café Blog Zone (a66042) — 2/6/2010 @ 6:33 pm[…] Mcnorman’s Weblog: Obama cries “uncle” finally! Patterico’s Pontifications: Obama Concedes on Health Care Reform? (Updated) On My Watch – the writings of SamHenry: Radical Lifestyle Changes Under Obama The Lonely […]
Mark Levin’s Scathing Opinion of Barack Obama’s Budget « Frugal Café Blog Zone (a66042) — 2/7/2010 @ 2:05 pm[…] Mcnorman’s Weblog: Obama cries “uncle” finally! Patterico’s Pontifications: Obama Concedes on Health Care Reform? (Updated) On My Watch – the writings of SamHenry: Radical Lifestyle Changes Under Obama The Lonely […]
Would “The Pizza Turnaround” Work for the GOP? (video) « Frugal Café Blog Zone (a66042) — 2/10/2010 @ 8:42 am[…] Mcnorman’s Weblog: Obama cries “uncle” finally! Patterico’s Pontifications: Obama Concedes on Health Care Reform? (Updated) On My Watch – the writings of SamHenry: Radical Lifestyle Changes Under Obama The Lonely […]
Another Promise Bites the Dust: Obama Now “Agnostic” about Raising Taxes on Middle-Class Families « Frugal Café Blog Zone (a66042) — 2/11/2010 @ 7:30 am[…] Weblog: Obama cries “uncle” finally! Patterico’s Pontifications: Now You Tell Us and Obama Concedes on Health Care Reform? (Updated) On My Watch – the writings of SamHenry: Radical Lifestyle Changes Under Obama The Lonely […]
Awesome: Andrew Klavan’s “President Me! The Musical” (video) « Frugal Café Blog Zone (a66042) — 2/13/2010 @ 1:18 pmHealth care should be for all, just like it is in the UK with their NHS program. It is not fair for people, citizens or immigrants to not be given access to health care just because they do not have insurance cover or have a pre conditioned illness. What are the taxes Americans pay for?
Myra Shields (b3ead8) — 2/28/2010 @ 12:44 pmwell they should be for the bare minimum needed to provide for national security, secure borders, and a few other bare necessities that are vital to the continued functioning of the country as a whole. everything else it properly the responsibilities of the various states, or the individual citizens. (see the 10th Amendment)
this does not include a national department of education, or one of “housing and urban development”, energy, PBS, NPR, NEA, or a host of other useless collections of bureaucrats.
individual health care is just that: an individual issue. it is NOT the purview of the state, nor should it be.
redc1c4 (fb8750) — 2/28/2010 @ 12:55 pm[…] to spend like a mad man Patterico’s Pontifications: Behind the Scenes at the White House and Obama Concedes on Health Care Reform? (Updated) Thomas Del Beccaro, Big Government: Judging Alito — Obama’s Ultimate Arrogance Bob […]
TigerText & Egos: A Comparison of Tiger Woods, Barack Obama, & Ronald Reagan « Frugal Café Blog Zone (a66042) — 3/3/2010 @ 7:40 am[…] Pontifications: “Because I’m the President” and Behind the Scenes at the White House and Obama Concedes on Health Care Reform? (Updated) Thomas Del Beccaro, Big Government: Judging Alito — Obama’s Ultimate Arrogance Bob […]
Obama’s Prez Approval Index Polling Numbers… Continue to Be Horrible at Negative 14, Similar to Failed Sitcom “Cavemen” (video) « Frugal Café Blog Zone (a66042) — 3/4/2010 @ 9:29 am[…] Pontifications: “Because I’m the President” and Behind the Scenes at the White House and Obama Concedes on Health Care Reform? (Updated) Thomas Del Beccaro, Big Government: Judging Alito — Obama’s Ultimate Arrogance Bob […]
“Why I’m a Conservative Republican”… Pay Attention, You Statists! (video) « Frugal Café Blog Zone (a66042) — 3/4/2010 @ 12:22 pm