Patterico's Pontifications

12/14/2009

ObamaCare: the not-unexpected cave-in on the public option

Filed under: General — Karl @ 7:04 pm

[Posted by Karl]

The White House pressured Sen. Maj. Ldr. Harry Reid to cut a deal with Sen. Joe Lieberman (I-CT), and hours later, liberal Sens. Tom Harkin and Jay Rockefeller said they would be willing to drop a “public option” government insurance program to win passage of a healthcare overhaul. It is unclear whether this development gets the Senate Democrats out of their weekly pep talk from Pres. Obama, or whether a photo-op chock full ‘o’ fauxmentum is coming tomorrow. Clearly, the White House is desperate to move Reid’s bill before Christmas. Dropping the public option gets the Dems closer to that goal, though how much closer remains unclear (e.g., the tax on “Cadillac” health insurance plans — which Big Labor hates — is among the issues still unresolved). Indeed, if the swing senators continue to throw up objections after the public option gets dropped, there will be a very real question of whether they ever want to get to “yes” for Harry.

This news will only intensify this morning’s netroots screeching. TNR’s Jonathan Chait claimed that “Lieberman is the beneficiary, or possibly the victim, of a cultural stereotype that Jews are smart and good with numbers.” However, unlike many of his unhinged pals on the Left, Chait understands the real game:

If Harry Reid decided to submit to Lieberman’s demands, the health care bill would basically revert to what the Senate Finance Committee produced. That’s still a major piece of legislation. Expectations among liberals have risen since then, so the come-down is understandable. But this isn’t the end of reform.

Bingo. It has been clear for some time that dropping the public plan is necessary, but not sufficient to defeat a government takeover of the US healthcare. The Obama administration has always been willing to dance the public option – mandate two-step. The cat is in the bag. The bag will be in the river unless the GOP — and public opinion — stop the Dems from forcing everyone in America to buy health insurance.

–Karl

3 Comments

  1. “The bag will be in the river unless the GOP — and public opinion — stop the Dems from forcing everyone in America to buy health insurance.”

    Karl – Agreed because the government’s various new unelected, faceless medical rationing and death panels get to set the minimum terms of the insurance coverage which must be offered to consumers. Bye, bye high deductible cat coverage plans. So much for Obama’s promises of choice. Another broken promise along with bringing down costs.

    Comment by daleyrocks (718861) — 12/14/2009 @ 10:51 pm

  2. Remember when there was all that talk about the Lieberman turd joining the Republicans? Damn good thing that never happened or they would calling this marxist medicine crap “bipartisan”.

    Comment by j curtis (5126e4) — 12/15/2009 @ 4:49 pm

  3. “Lieberman is the beneficiary, or possibly the victim, of a cultural stereotype that Jews are smart and good with numbers.”

    How is this language acceptable in a respectable publication? Oh, TNR? Might as well be Al Jazeera in more ways than one.

    If Fox News said something like this, it would result in congressional hearings. Does Chait have any basis for the idea that Joe was elected because he was Jewish or good with math? Or just a way to point out that he’s Jewish and not doing all he can for a handout bill? I know this is shocking, but being Jewish has no bearing on someone’s obligations.

    I’m still amazed at the idea this will survive a lawsuit. I’m going to start a denomination of Christianity preaching not buying health insurance unless you personally want it.

    Comment by Dustin (44f8cb) — 12/15/2009 @ 9:58 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.


Powered by WordPress.

Page loaded in: 0.2958 secs.