Patterico's Pontifications

2/26/2004

GOVERNMENT DISCRIMINATION AGAINST RELIGION UPHELD

Filed under: Court Decisions — Patterico @ 6:23 am

Eugene Volokh discusses yesterday’s Supreme Court decision in Davey v. Locke here. Volokh says that the case “held that states may discriminate against religious programs in distributing generally available benefits.”

In Volokh’s opinion, Justice Scalia’s dissent is more persuasive than the majority opinion. This observation could be applied to many landmark decisions issued by the Court in recent times. I believe that one day, Scalia will take his place next to Oliver Wendell Holmes as one of the great dissenters in Court history.

I haven’t had time to read the decision yet. However, if government has the power to discriminate against religious organizations, I wonder if the “logic” of the decision allows government to discriminate against only certain religious organizations. For example: “Here’s some money for you, and you — but nothing for the Jews.” When I read the decision, I will read it with an eye to answering that question.

Volokh describes the decision as resulting in

a regime where the government may discriminate against private religious institutions and programs, but may not discriminate in their favor. Now this is a wrong that is indeed worth amending the Constitution over.

Amen I certainly agree, brother.

3 Responses to “GOVERNMENT DISCRIMINATION AGAINST RELIGION UPHELD”

  1. BFL Roundup — Par Deu
    Conitnuing the roundup… Lil’ Miss Atilla isn’t pleased with GW. But that doesn’t mean she’s lost her head, either. Mike is assaulting Feinstein’s assault on assault weapons. Yes, Mike, it is sometimes hard being a Californian. Mr. Miller wonders how…

    Slings And Arrows (16154e)

  2. BFL Roundup — Part Deu
    Conitnuing the roundup… Lil’ Miss Atilla isn’t pleased with GW. But that doesn’t mean she’s lost her head, either. Mike is assaulting Feinstein’s assault on assault weapons. Yes, Mike, it is sometimes hard being a Californian. Mr. Miller wonders how…

    Slings And Arrows (16154e)

  3. BFL Roundup — Part Deu
    Continuing the roundup… Lil’ Miss Atilla isn’t pleased with GW. But that doesn’t mean she’s lost her head, either. Mike is assaulting Feinstein’s assault on assault weapons. Yes, Mike, it is sometimes hard being a Californian. Mr. Miller wonders how…

    Slings And Arrows (16154e)


Powered by WordPress.

Page loaded in: 0.1587 secs.